Skip to content
Shop
Explore

INDEPENDENT BMW ENGINE EXPERTISE

Trick the NOXEM?

N43 / N53 · NOXEM · DIAGNOSTICS

Select a technical image to view it in detail.

The “Mini Converter” Spacer, NOXEM and the N43 CO Catalytic Converter Faults

This entry is a bit different from the usual ones. I hope you find it interesting, and possibly even funny.

The inquiry

Some time ago, the owner of an N43 engine contacted me. He wanted to know whether the “inserts” for the control probes solve the error messages about the CO catalytic converters on these engines. He called these inserts “mini converters”, which suggests he had no basic knowledge of the subject.

I sent him several links to entries in this blog that explain how the performance of the CO catalytic converters on N-series engines is measured, and why such “converters” do not help. He stayed insistent. Several times he emailed to ask whether I had personally tested that the “mini converter” idea does not work, and he wanted me to test it and give him feedback.

Shortly afterwards he bought NOXEM, without any further questions. Apparently everything was clear to him. Then I received this email:

> So hello my friend- not really. > > I don’t know where to begin, but your noxem shit is not doing its job. I replaced nox catalyc converter with resonator and after 5km steady drive faults are back (2a26, 2a27, 29f5). So why say things you have not tried or don’t know? Wtf Mr master mind? So what is the point using noxem instead of original nox sensor? Maybe finish your programing before charging people for this fault code emulator? > > Feeling any responsability?

It looks as though this car has serious problems with its CO catalytic converters (they may even have been removed). I explained that these faults have nothing to do with the NOx system and relate to the CO catalytic converters.

Then came the next email:

> Dear professor, > > Actually you need to lern basics. > > I fixed your shit by using this (picture below). And now I explain for you how it works. > > N43b20 125kw engine has two co catalyc converters but only one probe to check efficiency of bank1, that one you know. Thing that you do not know is that second co catalyc converter efficiency is also measured, more like both banks at the same time, by nox sensor. In my case wideband sensor connected to your noxem. Ecu detects too quick mixture change and records co catalyc converter efficiency faults. > > After I installed that extension before noxem sensor, mixture signal is delayed and no fault codes recorded, system is fully operational, I just done 100km all kinds of driving, stratified charge 90-95% of that range was active. > > Fact is a fact, that extention fixed your shit, I do not understand how you made that emulator with “efficiency issue solving” in mind, but have not set simple mixture signal delay..

To back up his words, he sent a picture of his “performance”:

I believe this email deserves a closer look.

Does the control probe see only bank 1?

First, a closer look at whether the control probe on these engines really “sees” only the catalytic converter and mixture of bank 1. I marked the probe’s location with a red circle:

Does the probe really see only the first bank? Let’s look at the next stage of the exhaust system:

Here I marked in red the stage connected to the outlets of the catalytic converter in the previous image. As you can clearly see, both outlets are joined.

The conclusion is that the control probe sees BOTH banks. Technically this is not the best solution, but it works. It works for two simple reasons:

  • At idle and at low requested torque, which is when the efficiency of the CO catalytic converters is measured and the wideband probes are trimmed, the exhaust gas velocity is relatively low. The gases mix very well in this Y connection.
  • The exhaust gases do not flow evenly toward the outlet. The flow pulsates, and these pressure pulsations make the mixing more efficient.

Note: this link is a good example of how well the control probe “sees” an air leak located AFTER it, further along the exhaust.

Is the NOx sensor used to test the CO catalytic converters?

The email claims that the NOx sensor is used for the CO catalytic converter performance tests. I have to disappoint everyone who supports this idea:

  • The OEM NOx sensor is located too far down the exhaust system. Even if the sensor is in perfect condition, it cannot detect whether the CO catalytic converter has even minimal performance, because the exhaust gases are well mixed by the long pipe and the labyrinth of the NOx catalytic converter.
  • Measuring the overall performance of the catalytic converter this way is not possible, because the NOx catalytic converter is very “spacious”. It introduces a time delay that is hard to calculate and that also depends heavily on the condition of that catalytic converter.

No, the NOx sensor is NOT used to measure the performance of the CO catalytic converters.

Why were there no faults over 100 km?

What about his claim that he drove 100 km and everything is perfect? There are several possible explanations:

  • When the full functionality of the engine is restored (in this case, actually thanks to NOXEM), the DME resumes the injector and bank adaptations. In my experience, at least 80% of the error messages about CO catalytic converters are recorded not because the converters have completely lost their efficiency, but because they are overloaded: the engine delivers an incorrect fuel mixture and/or there are misfires. When the DME makes the injector and bank adaptations correctly, the misfire density drops as well, and the catalytic converters “recover”.
  • When NOXEM was installed, the DME restored stratified charge operation. Stratified charge gives the most comfortable fuel mixture (and thermal mode) for these catalytic converters, and it has a positive effect on their performance.
  • If the owner finally performed an engine re-adaptation (clearly he had not before, because nobody follows the RFML), the DME forcibly creates a new adaptation and allows a certain handicap before recording CO catalytic converter faults. This handicap exists for exactly such situations: to avoid UNJUSTIFIED error messages after a repair, while the initial adaptations are being created.

Conclusion

The true performance of the CO catalytic converters shows only after longer tests. It takes several hundred km and certain driving conditions to measure a CO catalytic converter. If the CO catalytic converter error messages appear later, the injector adaptations and the misfire density should be evaluated. Only when all adaptations are correct, the correct fuel mixture is confirmed by the mechanical efficiency of the cylinders, and the misfire density is 0 will the actual picture of the CO catalytic converters’ performance emerge.

Most probably, though, this person is not interested in any of this. I assume a new urban legend has been born: the positive effect of a NOx sensor spacer on CO catalytic converter error messages.

BEYOND THE FAULT CODE

A clearer picture.
A better next step.

Get in touch
Enlarged technical image
Open original image