Skip to content
Shop
Explore

INDEPENDENT BMW ENGINE EXPERTISE

Injectors from dealer. A safe purchase?

N43 / N53 · NOXEM · DIAGNOSTICS

Select a technical image to view it in detail.

Rusty and dirty “new” N43/N53 injectors from BMW dealers

This entry may be shocking, so a few comments first.

I have accurate and comprehensive information on every episode described here, and I will pass it to BMW AG headquarters.

It makes no sense to resolve these issues with the local dealer and the local certified service. Both companies have a terrible reputation, and even BMW AG’s audit attempts have failed. Untidy accounting, possible fraud in the accounting data, non-compliance with BMW AG procedures and unsatisfactory customer service are only some of the flaws. Unfortunately that is the reality, and there are obviously no better alternatives. BMW AG’s requirements are very high: becoming a dealer takes investments of millions of EUR, and few companies are ready to make them.

Now, everything in order.

The first dealer: dirty injectors, then the same ones cleaned

Since September 2021 there has been a shortage of injectors for N43/N53 engines. The local dealer told me they received small quantities of this now-sole product from time to time, so I decided to take a chance.

These are the injectors I was given. I inspected them at the dealer’s counter:

You can clearly see soot marks, and someone has handled an injector with bare hands (note the fingerprint). Can these be brand new injectors? In my opinion, no. I refused to buy them and returned them to the sales manager.

When I made this public, the dealer began threatening me with lawyers and serious trouble. At an impromptu meeting, the dealer manager pointed to the date on the injectors (early 2022) and claimed that this proved they were new and my claims were unfounded. I refused the injectors again. These injectors work at a pressure of 200 bar, and their nozzle openings are measured in microns. In my understanding, a new part cannot look like this.

Two weeks later I phoned the dealer anonymously to ask whether N43/N53 injectors were available. Yes, there were four pieces, and I was invited to come and collect them. I drove to the shop, and this is what I was offered:

These are the same injectors, only cleaned. The dealer clearly understood that new injectors cannot be dirty and carry fingerprints. Even so, they did not send them back to the supplier for exchange, and they did not ask the manufacturer or supplier for an explanation. They cleaned the injectors and tried to sell them to someone else, hiding the problem and cheating. Perhaps the dealer’s employees had fitted them to some cars to “test” them. I will never find out. Needless to say, I got no answer to my questions about how this is possible.

The second certified seller: a phantom stock and rusty injectors

At the same time I checked the situation at the second certified BMW parts seller.

Their stock showed 3 pieces available. My first attempt to buy them failed because of “a mistake in the system”, and the real stock was 0. Strangely, the mistake was never corrected, and the same quantity (3 pcs) stayed in the warehouse listing for the following month, until my second attempt.

A month later I came to this BMW partner anonymously and tried to buy the injectors again. This time there were injectors in stock, a miracle. This is what I received:

Are these new injectors? Significant rust is visible on them, and someone has again handled them with bare hands. The code on one of the boxes has been torn away. And these are the injectors that cost EUR 500 apiece?

The dealer’s staff could not give a credible explanation of anything: not when the injectors were ordered, not when they were delivered. They could not explain how the stock could be “incorrect” for months and then suddenly turn into real injectors. The manager’s attitude was simple: don’t buy if you don’t want to. I decided not to buy rusty injectors at EUR 500 each.

Why the rust matters

  • Speed of corrosion. The injectors are already this rusty after 2 to 7 weeks; the “freshest” one was manufactured on 16.03.2022, only two weeks before my purchase attempt. What will happen after a year, or after two or five years? Will they turn into piles of rust?
  • Rust inside. A part rusts on the inside as well as the outside. These injectors have been stored dry, so there is probably an enormous amount of fine rust powder inside them. In a working injector the inside is filled with fuel, and oxidation there is much slower because fuel contains far less oxygen than air. Rusting is, after all, oxidation of the metal by oxygen.
  • Stainless steel does not normally rust like this. The barrels (the metal body parts) are stainless steel. I have seen hundreds of these injectors, both new ones and used ones removed during replacement. Stainless steel does not rust, apart from the weld seams (more pronounced) and places where the thin natural oxide layer is damaged (less pronounced). This much rust is typical of injectors that have run for 5 to 10 years in humidity and high temperatures, which speed up oxidation. In an injector installed vertically in the cylinder head, the fine dust that comes loose “flows” from the seam down the barrel. Did such severe oxidation really happen in two weeks, or at most two months?
  • The body is fogged. The injector body looks as if it spent years in a humid, aggressive environment. This is not a new part. We are not even talking about a thin oxide layer; a thick layer of deposits is visible.

The main point to keep in mind is that rust is not acceptable in a fuel system.

Conclusion

I don’t know exactly what is going on. Perhaps some “refurbishing” program is delivering reconditioned injectors to BMW AG. Perhaps VDO found years-old injector blanks in its warehouses and has now marked and packaged them. Or perhaps something else is happening, probably a large-scale scam. Whatever the explanation, there must be no rust on injectors.

The situation is harsh. Unfortunately, you cannot trust even the dealer.

BEYOND THE FAULT CODE

A clearer picture.
A better next step.

Get in touch
Enlarged technical image
Open original image