Select a technical image to view it in detail.
In this article I look at how BMW reacted to its unsuccessful experience with the N43/N53 engines of the E series, and what that means for the F series.
Background: the E series
The N43/N53 engine family in E series cars was known for regular error messages from almost every system, especially the NOx system and uneven engine running. Fault 3104 (uneven running) was sometimes logged even when the car was simply driven on an uneven road.
So how do F series cars behave?
The case: F10 with an N53 engine
The owner of an F10 with an N53 engine came to me. The car had a NOx sensor error, and the NOx catalytic converter was diagnosed with insufficient performance. Mileage was over 270,000 km. The injector adaptations and cylinder performance adaptations had been completely lost. I installed a NOXEM and returned the car to the owner so the adaptations could be rebuilt by driving. After several hundred kilometres he reported that the car ran very unevenly. I did not take the new adaptations into account, assuming they were correct.
When I started the engine lukewarm (about 40 °C), it ran unevenly. Two observations stood out:
- The Lambda probe voltages were 1.95–2.05 V, so the Lambda of the whole bank was correct, around 1.00.
- The mechanical efficiency of the cylinders showed increased short-term deviations from 0, but no permanent imbalance. This means the individual fuel mixture of each cylinder was correct.
Regular misfires in almost all cylinders, despite a correct fuel mixture? It was time to check the ignition coils and spark plugs. According to the owner, the car had recently been serviced at another service centre, but who knows what that service included.
Ignition coils and spark plugs
I started with the appearance of the ignition coils. The damaged places where current leakage had occurred are marked in red.
This is what the spark plugs looked like:
The “maintenance” clearly included neither a spark plug replacement nor an assessment of the ignition coils. In this case the coils needed replacing, not just assessing. The spark plugs had obviously not been replaced 25,000 km earlier, nor 50,000 km, nor even 75,000 km.
Of course both the ignition coils and the spark plugs have to be replaced. But another aspect is even more interesting.
Misfire counters without fault codes
I let the engine idle for only a few minutes. As mentioned, the shaking was extreme and the misfires were regular; the engine shook continuously. I then checked the misfire counters:
Five of the six cylinders had misfire counters of 15 to 39, more than 100 events in total. Yet there were no error messages about uneven running, misfires or ignition problems.
This is the complete opposite of the E series (MSD80/81). The DME of an E series car would have logged faults immediately:
- misfire faults for the most affected cylinders;
- a multi-cylinder misfire fault, because the total number of misfires is overwhelming;
- fault 3104, if the engine tried to run in stratified charge mode.
Conclusion
Stratified charge cannot work properly with ignition components in this condition, as the images above show; misfires are guaranteed. As the engine warms up, it switches from stratified charge to homogeneous lean, and from there to homogeneous (emergency) mode. Still, there are no error messages.
Of course, BMW can “breathe easily”: there are fewer complaints. But the problem of uneven running has not gone away. Worse, driving for a long time with such misfires damages the whole exhaust system: the CO catalytic converters, the NOx catalytic converter, the Lambda probes and the NOx sensor.




