Skip to content
Shop
Explore

INDEPENDENT BMW ENGINE EXPERTISE

The defect of the NOx sensor?

N43 / N53 · NOXEM · DIAGNOSTICS

Select a technical image to view it in detail.

A BMW owner came to me with an unusual case. He had installed a new NOx sensor, but after only 400 km the error message 2AF8 appeared.

This code means the NOx sensor has indicated a reduced Lambda value in overrun mode. The typical cause is a clogged sensor probe. That does happen, and there are several possible reasons: increased engine oil consumption, certain fuel additives, water in the exhaust, or mechanical contamination. But clogging within 400 km seemed far too fast.

Checking the sensor data

The owner tested the NOx sensor data in overrun mode:

Lambda linear still reads 1.0, although it should be at least 15 to 20+. Lambda binary reads 544 mV. On this evidence the probe is completely clogged, or it has lost all ability to function.

The mechanic’s finding

I suggested removing the sensor for a visual inspection. The mechanic removed it and reported signs of thermal(?) damage to the wires. Here are some of his images:

His statement was that the sensor was clearly damaged and its wires had started to burn.

This is a serious claim. A burning wire can set the whole car on fire, so such cases deserve close attention. Still, the mechanic’s version sounds strange to me, and several arguments contradict it.

Why the sensor itself did not burn the wires

  • The sensor wires and their insulation tube are rated for working temperatures up to 800 °C. Permanent damage would require temperatures of several thousand °C, at which the metal conductor would start to melt. There are no signs of melting. At such temperatures there would also be burn damage elsewhere on the vehicle.
  • The wires have a cross-section of 0.75 mm² and are supplied through fuse 06, rated 10 A. They are short (70 cm), so they cannot carry enough heat to start burning. The power supply wires to the NOx sensor are also 0.75 mm² and much longer, so they would have started to melt first.
  • The sensor has no tracks “powerful” enough to carry 10 to 15+ A. In a complete short circuit, the wire to the sensor’s PCB would burn.
  • A short circuit inside the probe would have to be assumed, because in normal operation the current through the probe’s heating element is only about 1.0 A, which cannot damage the wires.
  • The black and yellow wires are the probe signal wires and carry only a few mA. Yet the black wire is exactly the one with the most damage.

It is quite clear to me that the wires did not burn because of damage to the sensor.

Could external heat have burned the wires?

The next possible scenario is that the wires burned from extremely high outside temperature. In theory this could happen in two ways:

  • The wires touched the exhaust, whose temperature may have exceeded 700 to 800 °C because of an incorrect fuel mixture.
  • The wires touched the drive shaft, where extreme rubbing could generate very high temperatures.

To see how the wires and their insulation behave under external heat, I put them through an extreme test. This video shows my attempt to burn the insulation tube:

The insulation tube does start to burn. Even after burning it for a longer time and shaking off the ashes, however, the insulation “frame” is still intact:

It looks completely different from the pictures the mechanic sent.

Then I tried to burn the wires themselves:

This was unsuccessful. Even after prolonged burning and cleaning off the soot, the wire insulation was not damaged at all.

My conclusion is clear: the defect is not thermal.

Mechanical damage

The defect must be mechanical. I took a file and damaged one wire (the white one) mechanically. This is the result:

Here are two of the mechanic’s images, in which I zoomed in on the damaged areas to make them clearer:

In my opinion there is no doubt that the wires were damaged mechanically. They are crushed and scratched.

How this could have happened

There are two likely explanations:

  • The mechanic did not properly secure the wires or route them under the decorative cover.
  • The car hit an obstacle, which damaged the wires. Had the wires been properly secured, such damage would not have been possible.

Either way, the mechanic’s unprofessional work caused a loss of several hundred EUR in a single moment. I also believe he saw the consequences of his work when he removed the damaged sensor and understood very well that his own mistake had caused the damage. Instead, he chose to hide it and lied to the car owner. That will remain on his conscience. It is also possible that the owner, or the car’s user, kept quiet about an unsuccessful maneuver to avoid unexpected costs.

The damaged wires created a short circuit between them, which permanently damaged the electronics of the sensor and probe. Unfortunately, such a sensor cannot be saved.

Do not entrust the repair of your car to non-professionals!

BEYOND THE FAULT CODE

A clearer picture.
A better next step.

Get in touch
Enlarged technical image
Open original image