Select a technical image to view it in detail.
I am publishing a series of articles on VANOS problems, and this first one covers a defect that affects most BMW petrol engines. Even most new cars, including some still under warranty, have minor or more significant problems with this unit. The defect described here and in the following chapters is something most users and repair specialists never suspect.
This series is not a replacement for VANOS gear and mechanism articles, and it is not for those who favor repair kits. On N series engines I have never had problems with the mechanism’s performance, except where it was assembled incorrectly after an unjustified “repair”. Whenever I learned that the mechanisms had been replaced during a VANOS repair, I never got confirmation that the repair was objectively necessary. When I ask why the mechanism was replaced, the typical answer is: “Well, there were error messages regarding VANOS…” When I ask about live data, valve PWM values or other measurements, I have never received any. Until I see evidence to the contrary, I believe the VANOS mechanisms of N (and B) series engines are very long-lived, and replacing them is certainly not where a VANOS repair should start.
Nor will these articles cover simple defects such as a broken solenoid winding. Those are identified by error messages in the DME fault memory and need no special knowledge. I will write about performance problems, that is, situations where the DME fault memory most probably holds no error messages (yet, or at all) and the defect is “hiding”.
The basics in Q&A
Q. Which engines suffer from these VANOS performance problems? A. All N and B series petrol engines, because they all have VANOS on both the inlet and outlet camshafts.
Q. What is the cause? A. Unequivocally, long oil change intervals. Even one or two intervals of 30 .. 35,000 km on the same oil can be, and often are, the cause.
Q. How many cars are affected? A. Very roughly, at least 4 out of 5 cars under 100,000 km already have (hidden) problems with this unit. The symptoms may not be noticeable yet, or the existing issues may be blamed on other components, and no error messages may have been recorded in the DME. Even so, the problems are clearly visible during diagnostics.
Q. Which VANOS unit, inlet or outlet, is more prone to problems? A. In 90% of cases the outlet unit is the first to show the problem.
Q. How can VANOS problems be avoided? A. Change the oil regularly, at least every 10,000 km, and drive dynamically, which helps keep the VANOS valves clean.
Q. Why should these problems be fixed as soon as possible? A. All the mechanical Valvetronic parts wear much faster if the engine has VANOS performance problems: the motors, bearings, worm gear, eccentric shaft and roller drag lever. The electronic throttle and the CO catalytic converters also wear out much faster. If the wear of these parts exceeds the norm, the repair will be expensive.
How the problem develops
Leaving aside damage to a particular unit, the most common VANOS problem can be divided into three phases:
- Phase 1: the valve is partially clogged. The DME (and the valve solenoid) must use additional power to hold the required camshaft position, and the PWM jitter of the solenoid increases significantly.
- Phase 2: the valve continues to clog. The DME can no longer hold the camshaft position. The short-term deviation of the camshaft position grows, so the jitter of the shaft position increases.
- Phase 3: the valve is so badly clogged that the camshaft position can no longer be held. The actual position differs more and more from the required one, and the VANOS unit fails permanently.
Symptoms in each phase
Phase 1. The user notices no symptoms, and the engine runs correctly if it has no other problems. Increased roughness may appear during “non-standard” processes, for example during desulfation on N43/N53 engines or when warming up a cold B series engine. It is usually blamed on something else, such as injectors, fuel or the ignition system (spark plugs, injectors). The DME fault memory holds no error messages. Camshaft positions in INPA/ISTA live data are stable. Short-term shivering may be felt during transitions, such as a swift change in required torque or a gear shift, but other components are usually blamed. The problem shows up only in advanced diagnostics.
Phase 2. The following symptoms appear:
- The idle becomes more restless, as if there were “partial” misfires.
- On the move, the car seems to push or jerk.
- On N43/N53 engines the shivering is particularly pronounced during desulfation.
- On B series engines, idle shivering starts within the first minute after starting a cold or cool engine.
Again, these symptoms are often written off to injectors, ignition problems, the fuel system (pressure jitter) and so on. In the problematic driving conditions the camshaft position, typically of the outlet shaft, jitters by ±5 .. 10 degrees or even more. The problem is now visible in “standard” diagnostics when checking live data. There are still no error messages in the DME fault memory.
Phase 3. Error messages finally appear in the DME fault memory about VANOS being unable to reach or hold the required position. The typical condition for logging the error is a difference between required and actual camshaft position of at least 20 degrees for 1 .. 3 seconds. Then:
- The VANOS unit is disabled.
- Engine power is reduced. For example, the available torque on a B58 drops from 450+ Nm to 360 Nm.
- Accelerator pedal response slows down.
- The engine becomes “clumsy”, with no sharpness and no power.
If you delete the error messages and start a new driving session, the DME tries to restore VANOS operation, but live data now shows that the camshaft position is unstable. In problematic conditions VANOS is disabled again and again.
Cause: a clogged regulating valve
The reason for all this is quite simple: the regulating valve clogs. The cause is infrequent oil changes. Even one or two of the 30 .. 35,000 km oil change intervals recommended by BMW are enough for the outlet VANOS unit to suffer severely, even with a suitable driving profile and a significant average speed.
Why the outlet unit?
My experience shows that it is precisely the outlet VANOS that suffers. With dynamic driving, the inlet VANOS valve can serve for a long time (200 .. 300,000 km and more), while the outlet VANOS often fails before 100,000 km.
My first thought was that the oil channels in the engine block might be arranged so that the outlet valve (its strainer) partly acts as a filter. Or perhaps the oil flow is higher at the inlet VANOS valve, so it can “flush” dirt away better. I do not have images of all the oil channels of all engine blocks, but in those I do have, both VANOS valves are fed through separate channels from the common oil rail, so that is not the explanation.
Next I wondered whether the narrow VANOS working range was to blame. On N and B series engines the typical adjustment range of the inlet/outlet VANOS is 70/60 degrees. In real driving the inlet uses a range of at least 65 degrees, while the outlet uses only 35 .. 40 degrees. Perhaps the outlet VANOS works only partially and therefore does not clean itself? No: analysis of PWM data shows that the inlet valve is not in a much better situation.
The last hypothesis is that the outlet VANOS valve is not cleaned because it is practically closed most of the time, so the oil that gets inside is never flushed out. The inlet VANOS, by contrast, works actively all the time, provided you drive at least close to the performance BMW intended. The outlet VANOS is used actively when the CO catalytic converters are warming up and, on N43/N53 engines, during desulfation of the NOx catalytic converter.
Unfortunately, it looks as if we BMW owners have no option other than changing the engine oil often to prolong the life of VANOS.
Available diagnostic data
INPA. The most comprehensive data comes from the MSD80 DME. For this DME we can see the camshaft reference positions and the required and detected positions.

In the test block the PWM of the valves can be seen.

For older Siemens DMEs, valve PWM data is not available. Bosch DMEs typically do not offer PWM data either.
ISTA. ISTA typically gives only the detected camshaft positions.

In the ISTA test blocks, the required and detected positions of the tested shaft are typically displayed, and the test has to be run separately for each shaft. The image shows a VANOS test on a BX8 engine.
