Skip to content
Shop
Explore

INDEPENDENT BMW ENGINE EXPERTISE

B58. Worn out spark plugs. Part 2

N43 / N53 · NOXEM · DIAGNOSTICS

Select a technical image to view it in detail.

This entry continues the topic of uneven running on the B58.

Symptoms

At low RPM (below 2000, most noticeable around 1000 to 1500) and minimal requested torque, the engine runs unevenly. The symptoms are progressing, and over time the idle has also become restless.

The spark plugs were replaced 15,000 km ago, which initially solved the problem. I did not fit aftermarket or OE-supplier equivalents, but genuine BMW plugs bought from a BMW dealer. Both electrodes, including the side one, are made of precious metal. Catalogs give a quite impressive service life for this plug type: 100,000 km. Plug life should really be counted in cycles (or, at worst, engine hours), and it will be shorter in city traffic. Even so, 10,000 to 15,000 km cannot be the end of these plugs.

Obviously, the problem lies somewhere else.

The dealer

The car is still under warranty, so I contacted a dealer. Petrol engines, let alone the B58, are rare in our area, so I was not surprised that the dealer’s specialists had never heard of such a problem. The head of the dealer center offered diagnostics for EUR 80 to 160, during which the DME fault memory would be read. I objected that there were no fault entries in the DME, which confused him. He said they had no idea, but could open a case and ask BMW specialists for advice.

I had hoped BMW had released a software update (the car’s integration level was last updated two years ago), but the dealer’s specialist disappointed me: there are no DME software updates.

The main DME software problems relating to uneven running are these:

  • In the EDIABAS call-up function list, misfires are not reported at all.
  • When shifting gears (on a manual transmission), misfire registration is not blocked. Misfires are regularly logged during gear changes without justification.
  • The misfire registration threshold is fixed and high, so misfires at low requested torque are not registered.

On the subject of misfires, then, the dealer is quite helpless. To identify misfires at all, you have to take a test drive with iCOM connected and Expert mode activated.

I concluded that this time the dealer would not be able to help, so I had to solve the problem myself.

Checking the misfire counters

As a first step, I checked the misfire counters via OBD Mode 6.

Note: the B58 shows its misfire counters in the opposite order from the N53/54/55 and similar engines. The long-term counters come first, and the counters for the last driving session come after.

The long-term counters are 6/5/7/5/5/6. As I mentioned before, on a manual transmission random-cylinder misfire events are recorded every time a gear is changed. What matters in these data is that the counters of all cylinders are very similar. So the spurious gear-change misfires evidently dominate, and no cylinder shows additional misfires. How can that be? What could have happened to all these cylinders?

I checked the rough run data in Expert mode during actual driving. Indeed, uneven running is present in all cylinders.

Incorrect mixture? I checked: lambda is around 1.0, so that is fine.

Incorrect injection timing? I would not be surprised, but then there would be a louder outcry, at least on the Internet.

Checking whether the DME misses misfires

I checked once more whether the DME was missing some misfires in the problem mode. The procedure was:

  • Choose a longer stretch of road where I can drive at 60 to 80 km/h.
  • Reach 80 km/h and shift into 6th gear.
  • Record the misfire counter data in OBD Mode 6.
  • Drive in the problem mode without changing gears.
  • After a certain time, record the misfire counter data again.
  • Compare the readings before and after the drive.

The result was no registered misfire events, even over a longer time. As far as the DME is concerned, everything was fine.

Suspecting the spark plugs

What could have happened to all the cylinders? Injector problems? Damaged ignition coils? Neither sounds credible. The only credible cause I could imagine is the spark plugs. But what could have happened to them?

Here is a typical view of the power and torque displays when driving at around 90 km/h:

The requested torque is around 50 to 60 Nm, slightly above 10% of the maximum, and the power is only a few percent of the maximum. Clearly, the spark plugs are working in a normal mode here.

A short digression: one of the basic spark plug parameters is the heat number (heat range). Basic information is here.

My theory is that, because the driving is too gentle, the plugs do not reach their self-cleaning temperature. Carbon deposits then form on the insulator and the plugs perform worse. Lately COVID has been raging in Europe, and during these 10,000 km I had little chance to drive in a more appropriate mode. Speed limits of 50/90 km/h and driving in traffic among compact-class cars are not the most suitable conditions for a B58. The theory has a basis.

Test drive and conclusion

During the last holidays I had a chance to test this theory. For half an hour I drove more aggressively, at an average speed of 120 km/h.

After this drive, the problem was significantly reduced. The cause is evidently an operating temperature that is too low.

Several BMW enthusiast forums discuss “colder” spark plugs, which are used after various B58 upgrades (power increases). In my case, because of the gentle driving, “hotter” plugs would have been the helpful choice. Unfortunately, BMW itself does not offer different spark plug versions for different driving modes. The only solution is evidently to use the B58 in an appropriate driving mode.

BEYOND THE FAULT CODE

A clearer picture.
A better next step.

Get in touch
Enlarged technical image
Open original image