Skip to content
Shop
Explore

INDEPENDENT BMW ENGINE EXPERTISE

How to evaluate a used car

N43 / N53 · NOXEM · DIAGNOSTICS

In this entry I describe how I choose a used BMW for purchase.

Start with the options you actually want

Everyone has desired features and a list of “must-have” options, and there is no shortage of myths, oddities and prejudice around them. The only advice I can offer is to gather information about each feature and take a test drive in a car that has it. You may find, for example, that a HUD is almost useless because all you see is the speed. Ventilated seats may do nothing except give you health problems (a frozen back) in summer.

Assume you already have a list, or even a shortlist, of potential dream cars. How do you evaluate them?

Stage one: gathering initial information

Ask for the VIN and evaluate the available photos. Check whether the shade of color is the same in all of them, since different shades indicate replaced or repainted parts. Evaluate the condition of the interior. Interior condition does not indicate mileage, but if it is worn out, I doubt you will enjoy driving the car.

Check the car’s equipment with a VIN decoder. Make sure the car is not a “constructor” (assembled from parts) and that none of the original options have gone missing. Check the data from the latest technical inspections (TIs).

You can order the car’s history from Auto DNA, CarVertical or similar services, but keep in mind that these data are only indicative. If there are records of a modified odometer or serious crashes, keep away. If there are no such records, unfortunately, that means nothing. People hide crashes and modify odometers. Hundreds of companies make thousands of odometer-modification tools, and many repairers work in the grey sector and fix cars whose owners never report accidents to the police or insurers. For this reason, 99% of the information about a car can only be gathered in person.

BMW AOS. The Aftersales Online system shows not only planned and completed recall campaigns but also records in BMW’s servers. The newer the car, the more useful the information. Together with information from the local dealer, AOS data gives an initial picture of the vehicle: whether maintenance was done at the dealer, and how often the owner had the defects covered by recall campaigns fixed. These data matter. Some recall campaigns replaced very expensive parts, for example the HPFP and piezo injectors (such a set would cost you 2000 to 3000 EUR).

On-site inspection

Interior

I have said several times that interior wear has no direct connection to a car’s mileage. Still, a worn-out interior is an argument for choosing a different car, one with low mileage (even if the figure is true). I stress that a good interior does NOT mean the car has low mileage or low wear in motor hours.

Body

I check whether the shade of any body part differs from the others, and whether the gaps between body parts match the specification. I check whether the replaceable parts (front wings, hood, trunk lid, doors) have been replaced, and I measure paint thickness with a paint thickness gauge.

The most critical question is whether load-bearing structures and non-replaceable parts have been repaired, and how well. To answer it, you have to know how the car is painted at the factory. I have spent a lot of time studying the nuances of BMW’s manufacturing process. You need to know:

  • what the paint thickness should be at each point of the body;
  • which body parts get a clear coat and which do not;
  • which seams are sealed at the factory;
  • what kind of bolts the manufacturer uses, and so on.

The aim is to understand whether body parts have been repaired and how seriously. I also evaluate the engine supports and other components in the engine compartment. Sometimes the data on the headlights, seat belts and window glass help to reveal inconsistencies.

Note. I have seen an F series car put together from two or even three cars so well that the initial inspection showed nothing suspicious. All parts had factory paint. The repairers had hidden the seams under the roof rails, under the sill on the floor, and at the front under the wing. The replaceable body parts came from another car with the same color code.

The moral applies to this and every other stage of inspection: the more experience you have, the less likely you are to miss something important. Cars that look completely “clean” should also be inspected very carefully. The argument “it’s a cheap car, nobody will bother with complicated repairs” does not hold up. The car was expensive once, and such tricks paid off.

SRS

Of course you must read the SRS error messages with diagnostic tools, but there are tricks that make computer diagnostics show nothing suspicious. So I also evaluate the SRS elements visually. I check:

  • that the side airbags are present;
  • the front airbag;
  • the steering wheel and instrument panel airbags;
  • the condition of the pyrotechnic cartridge on the battery.

If the car is missing any SRS component, I reject it immediately.

If the equipment is in order, the car has not suffered serious damage, and the SRS was restored after any minor crash, it is worth connecting the diagnostic equipment.

Computer diagnostics

I should say up front that if you don’t have at least ISTA and INPA (both BMW AG diagnostic software), don’t waste your time. With a “universal” tool you will see almost nothing.

ISTA. I use ISTA for a quick overall picture. The total number of error messages and their content tell me a “story” about the car’s life. The seller will of course insist that the errors appeared because the battery was low, that they “don’t mean anything”, and so on. It’s a classic. The general picture does tell me whether the car has ever been maintained. But the presence or absence of error messages means NOTHING by itself, because deleting them right before the customer arrives takes five minutes.

INPA. INPA gives me access to the History and Info memory of the main modules. A dealer does not see these data even with ISTA, let alone with universal tools, so there is a better chance of finding something interesting. If the History data have also been deleted, that is a signal to me that someone is diligently hiding something.

I also use INPA to inspect live data from the main modules, such as the engine and gearbox. Modern engines and gearboxes are so complicated that error messages say little about their technical condition. Live and adaptation data are another matter. You need serious knowledge and experience, but with them the picture gets clearer, and you can evaluate the condition of the injectors and other expensive components.

Activating test modules and components lets you check the operation of the most important and temperamental systems, for example the pneumatic suspension and the panoramic sunroof.

ISTA/CBS. CBS holds the car’s maintenance data. It shows how many times brake pad replacement, oil changes, and coolant and brake fluid changes were registered. You can see whether the battery was registered and, on diesels, whether the DPF was replaced, along with the replacement intervals. Very often these data tell a lot, or make you ask a lot of questions. You can also spot cheating here, for example “replaced” DPFs with no physical replacement, or five brake pad changes on a car with a supposed mileage of 80,000 km.

Mileage and odometer modification

Note. Mileage is only one of the parameters that describe a car’s wear. The second most important is motor hours. The third is the specific way the car was used, which I cover here. All three should be checked and evaluated together.

Finally, a few words on odometer modification. The days when this “operation” cost a lot of money are gone. The E series (E6X, E9X, especially E65) was quite well protected. A long time ago, modifying an E65 odometer cost up to 1000 USD; now it costs just a few tens of EUR.

With the F series the situation is even worse. Modifying an F series odometer is very simple, and it is even possible to “block” it: with a special tool the odometer “freezes” and the km count no longer changes. Because modification is so simple and cheap, many BMWs have their odometers modified before each TI and before each dealer visit. Odometer readings and BMW database reports must be treated very critically. Cheating is very common: without exaggeration, in the cheap price segment around 90% of 10-year-old cars have some kind of odometer manipulation.

The situation changes with the latest F series cars (after software changes) and with the G series. All their data (telematics, live data, etc.) are regularly and automatically uploaded to BMW AG servers without the driver’s knowledge. So when you query AOS, you can get broad information about how the car was used.

Running gear

Inspecting the running gear is the last and simplest stage, but I suggest having it done at a specialized workshop too. If you don’t know the nuances, you can make mistakes that later cost several thousand in repairs. However, if a control arm or an axle box needs replacing, that is definitely not a reason to refuse the car.

Directly after purchase

What should you do right after buying? Wash it, of course. But also install the necessary security systems, arrange insurance, and carry out maintenance. The minimum is:

  • Replace the engine oil and oil filter, the engine air filter and the cabin air filter.
  • Replace the filter and oil in the automatic gearbox if the mileage is above 120,000 km.
  • Replace the timing chain on N and B series diesel engines if the mileage is 200,000 km or more.
  • Replace the DPF on diesel cars if the mileage is 200,000 km or more.

Unfortunately, that is the reality of BMW diesels. At 200,000 km or more, which is a very common situation, maintenance costs right after purchase can reach 3500 to 4000 EUR. If you skip this maintenance, you endanger your health and that of others, first of all your passengers, by breathing in particulate matter. You may also end up paying even more if the engine chain breaks or the gearbox loses gears.

BEYOND THE FAULT CODE

A clearer picture.
A better next step.

Get in touch
Enlarged technical image
Open original image