Skip to content
Shop
Explore

INDEPENDENT BMW ENGINE EXPERTISE

B58. VANOS repair. Part 1

N43 / N53 · NOXEM · DIAGNOSTICS

Select a technical image to view it in detail.

I bought my 4 Series BMW from a BMW AG dealership in Germany, where it had been returned directly after a three-year lease (warranty). The dealer offered an additional one-year warranty. Note, however, that this was not a BMW AG extended warranty but a different arrangement.

The warranty in Germany

In Germany, a “warranty” is actually insurance against technical damage, and it is widespread. The seller pays the insurer a few percent of the vehicle’s value, and the insurer covers repair costs for damage during the insurance period. In my case the insurer is Zurich, which has re-insured its risks further. So I don’t have to worry that the dealership might reorganize or “disappear” because the car was bought in another country.

This is what the warranty/insurance contract looks like:

The problem and how I found it

The car had had only two oil changes. It had been driven on German highways at an average speed of 60 km/h, which is not demanding. Anyone who understands cars will probably agree that this is little more than a “warm-up” for a BMW. Still, the engine did not run quite right. The spark plugs had been replaced “outside the schedule”. I replaced them once more and dealt with their carbon residues, then updated the DME software and readapted the engine. Part of the problems disappeared, but some unevenness in engine performance remained. I describe the symptoms in Part 2.

I had the symptoms but no confirmation of the cause. Then I got lucky. Less than two months before the warranty ended, BMW AG released the newest ISTA, which added an expert mode for the VANOS hub and an upgraded VANOS test module. Together these tools let me identify the problem immediately: because of infrequent oil changes, the VANOS management valves were clogged.

The fault is not complicated, but replacing the valve means dismantling “half of the engine”. On previous-generation engines this repair took 10 minutes. On the B-series engines it requires 12 special tools and a full working day.

I would gladly leave this repair to the dealer, with the insurance paying for it.

Dealing with the dealer and the insurer

I prepared the technical information and presented it to the car’s seller straight away. It was crucial not to lose even a day, so that the warranty would not expire. The seller sent me the insurer’s contact details within a day. The next day I went to the local dealership, Inchcape Latvia, with a formal problem application. I submitted:

  • a description of the symptoms;
  • printouts of the expert-mode graphs, with explanations;
  • a request to run the VANOS hub test module (a functional check with the dealer’s diagnostic tool).

The picture shows the documents I prepared for the dealer’s technicians.

The sequence of events below gives a rough idea of the time and energy involved.

I waited two weeks for diagnostics at the dealer center. During that session the dealer:

  • did not analyze the expert-mode data I supplied and did not analyze hub performance (apparently expert mode is normally used only by BMW AG engineers);
  • ran the test module and found that the VANOS hub could not complete it. This was good news for me, because it confirmed the problem was still there;
  • carried out a test drive, but the employee did not notice any uneven performance.

Since the test module failed, Inchcape Latvia contacted the warranty insurer. The insurer then asked for additional diagnostics to clarify the cause. The dealer’s specialists ran a second diagnostic session, including an oil pressure check, which makes sense because VANOS operation depends on oil. I waited another two weeks for it.

The oil pressure check showed no problems. The verdict of the Inchcape Latvia specialists, which ISTA also gives, was that the VANOS hub solenoids and management valves should be replaced. They sent this to the insurer.

The insurer did not give in easily. Although I had reported the problem before the oil change, it asked for documents showing when, by whom, how, with what and why the oil change was done. I had changed the oil during the month in which both diagnostic sessions took place. I supplied the documents within 24 hours, then waited more than a month for the decision.

The favorable decision came almost three months after I reported the problem. By then the “case” file had grown to 40–50 pages. Only then could the repair begin.

The picture shows the list of replaced parts:

Costs and coverage

Including service costs, this repair would have cost a customer EUR 1200. The EUR 300 I saved on two additional oil changes outside the “standard” intervals therefore left me EUR 900 worse off. BMW is not a car on which to “save” money. Oil change intervals of 30–35,000 km are not right even for highway driving.

One more nuance: the insurer covered 100% of the repair work but only 80% of the spare parts. I don’t know exactly why the parts coverage was reduced. Inchcape Latvia suggested it might be because the dealer did not perform the last oil change.

My own possible explanations:

  • In its estimate, Inchcape Latvia priced the parts at list price (with a formal 15% discount), even though the problem appeared while all operating requirements were met and the oil change intervals were not exceeded.
  • The damaged element was not known precisely (solenoid, valve or both), so all possible “culprits” were replaced.
  • A defect of the VANOS intake camshaft was not mentioned in the initial application. It emerged only during the test, which was sometimes even passed.

The insurer also refused to cover the diagnostics, so I paid for both sessions myself.

The picture shows my co-payment for the repair parts:

Conclusion

If anyone believes that insurance or a warranty means no problems, they are wrong. I identified the fault myself, prepared all the technical information, and was willing to stand up for my rights. Even so, the process took three months. I spent several days at the dealer center and paid a co-payment of around EUR 250.

It seems slightly comical that a EUR 1200 case consumed so many human resources. I am sure that administering it cost more than the repair and insurance payout combined.

Part 2 covers the symptoms of the problem, the technical data before and after the repair, and the results.

BEYOND THE FAULT CODE

A clearer picture.
A better next step.

Get in touch
Enlarged technical image
Open original image