Skip to content
Shop
Explore

INDEPENDENT BMW ENGINE EXPERTISE

BMW. Wtf?

N43 / N53 · NOXEM · DIAGNOSTICS

Select a technical image to view it in detail.

In this entry I summarize a handful of nuances that raise questions I can’t answer. As you can guess, they are not the “wow, how cool, how did they manage that?” kind. Some may call them small stuff, but I don’t. If you have similar topics to suggest, feel free to comment.

This time the nuances of the F32 LCI “stepped on a nerve”, because I had the chance to drive this car more. I have driven other F-series cars too, but I always try to be fair: you have to get used to each car. Some things in this one I simply couldn’t get used to.

Electric power steering

BMW has used electric power steering for a long time now. I understand that in the first generation an uninformative steering feel was forgivable. But in 2021? Current models (just out of production, with software updates still being issued) subjectively have a steering response curve shaped like the letter V. At small steering angles the response is almost zero, even in Sport mode, so the wheel feels as if it “hangs in the air”. On conventional steering systems the curve looks more like a Y. Even a very slight turn of the wheel meets some resistance, created by friction in all the suspension mechanisms and links, and this resistance also helps you “feel” the wheel.

Another peculiar point: in Sport mode the virtual steering assist is also reduced at speeds close to 0. The wheel is therefore “heavy” when parking, turning out of a yard or turning at an intersection. Why? So that the “athlete” doesn’t get weak? That is the only explanation I can think of, and otherwise it is simply dumb. All of this could be changed in software. Or does everyone else believe the electric steering assist works perfectly?

Turn signal stalk

A long time ago I read that BMW drivers had trouble getting used to the electronic turn signal switch in the E6x. It does take time, but I came to love it. Now the mechanical stalk is back, and there is a problem. The electric steering column makes the steering ratio more direct, so the driver turns the wheel as little as possible. In a shallow turn, the wheel moves through such a small angle that the turn signal does not cancel afterwards. You can get used to anything, but I’m sorry, this is a fail. The cancel angle should be electronic and adaptive.

Wiper stalk

The second stalk that was simplified is the wiper stalk. If it is in automatic mode, you can no longer press it to trigger 1–2 wipe cycles. If it is in the OFF position, pulling it toward you to trigger 1–2 cycles also starts the screen wash at the same moment. BMW saved some EUR. Maybe even two EUR.

NBT EVO ID5: browsing music on a USB drive

I would like to meet in person the dumbasses, sorry, the talented people who programmed this “wonder”. There are probably many masterpieces of similar level in it, but the first “service” of my USB drive was what gave me the wow feeling.

I’m old-school and patient, and I prefer to keep my music on USB flash drives. There are several reasons. Some artists (from the strange side) are not on Spotify. Sometimes mobile coverage is poor, so the music has to be downloaded to the phone for offline mode. And storing all my music on the phone doesn’t sound logical to me.

So I put my music on the USB drive and started browsing the content. I chose, for example, Search by Artists. Here is an example:

In the Andy Moore album (as an example), he is listed as the artist, and there are also songs with “guest stars”. All of this appears in one long list. When I select any of these entries, the screen shows the album where that exact “artist” entry can be found. But I CANNOT select that album. I can only select one exact track, where the artist field is the current artist (exactly, up to the comma). I CANNOT play the whole album. I also CANNOT play all songs of that artist if they are spread over different albums. Worst of all, this menu has no UP/DOWN options. It would be enough if pressing UP moved the highlight to the album name so I could select it, and pressing DOWN let me select all songs of that artist. But no, nothing like that. Do the developers themselves really enjoy this creation?

I thought the following trick might work: select a song, then switch to Search by artist (or the reverse: first the artist, then the song). If the search “cursor” corresponded in both menus, maybe I could somehow reach playback of the album or all songs. NO, and NO again! The search in these menus is completely unrelated and starts from the “beginning” every time. Search by track numbers, for example, sorts all 2000+ songs by file name, and does it completely “dumbly”. The track number is not stripped, other redundant symbols such as “_”, “/” and “.” are ignored, and the songs play in exactly this order, “by the name”. And again, I CAN NOT select the exact artist or album, although they are nicely displayed on the screen, just inactive. Am I the only one who thinks this menu was invented by “geniuses”? And this is 2020, with the software update done at the end of 2019. BMW, aren’t you ashamed?

Here is an example. I select a track by Andy Moore plus a guest artist. NBT generously lets me choose what to play: the album or the song. I choose the album. Then comes the surprise: the whole album is not played (all its songs are neatly copied into one folder), only that one current track. No other tracks of the album!

And here is another example:

It doesn’t even matter that I have to get to the exact track: the Artist and Album fields are inactive. I CANNOT choose to play the current album or all tracks of the current artist. Either that one song gets played 100 times in a row, or all 2000+ tracks play “by the name”, in a complete mess. As you can see in the image, NBT has selected tracks whose names start with 03. It doesn’t understand that this is a track number. No, everything is exactly as the programmers wrote it, no deviation. In case the point is unclear, every track in this list is by a different artist. The list shows track names but ZERO additional information. Even for the track selected by the cursor, neither artist nor album name is shown in the list. So I have a list of 2000+ songs WITHOUT any additional information. You wanted tracks by name? Here you go.

All search menu positions are lost whenever I switch to another menu for a moment. If I switch to the navigation map and return to the Search menu, the system has forgotten all history.

I have to admit that even the prehistoric CCC is not so “dumb”. Compared with this, using CCC is a pleasure.

The data structure on my USB drive is straightforward: Artist name / Artist name + Album / Songs. It really is that simple.

Navigation: map display

I can already hear the first skeptics protesting: come on, enough about audio issues. No problem, let’s switch to navigation. I swear I was not specifically looking for 1 of 1000 cities that can’t be found quickly. These were my first 5 minutes with the excellent NBT EVO.

First, the indication of the general direction is gone. That was a mega feature of CCC. You may not follow the exact instructions of the navigation, but you know whether you are driving in the right direction or the wrong one.

OK, I tried the Auto-zoom option. In 8 of 10 cases the screen shows the overall trip (when no maneuver is needed). But at least 20% of the time Auto-zoom failed. Why? Obviously an excellent job by the programmers.

The Perspective view option did not get better either. Instead of a real perspective view (which CCC actually has), it is a slightly tilted map whose top part does not match the meaning of perspective. One more nuance has to be taken into account. The top part of the map is compressed about 2 times to create the “perspective” feeling, which means the scale shown for the map is not true in its middle part. The error is around 50%: 50 km on the NBT screen is actually 75 km. Sometimes that can matter a lot.

It’s 2021, but when you turn in the opposite direction, nothing has changed in this mega product since the first navigation systems. Even CCC showed the U-turn sign, this one:

Outside built-up areas, you can drive for miles in the wrong direction without knowing it.

Even more: the main road, which is colored red by default, turns white on the part you must follow. With local roads it is worse. They are white by default, and only a slightly thicker contour tells you that you have to drive on them.

How do you know you have to turn back? Here, the red dot! Oh, not turn back but turn right? Here, a slightly thicker contour. Does anyone find this very convenient? Really?

The biggest BMW fans will protest that it can NOT be SO bad. I admit this was the “Alternative view”. What other options are available? “Standard view”. How does it differ? The route is blue. That’s it. I remind you that this is not an alpha-stage project where the development team decided in a meeting: “well, here we’ll have a bullet point with 3+ views. For now we have one, the second is route coloring, well, you know, we’ll fill it in later.” No, this is a finished product.

Steering wheel buttons

Another “pleasant” nuance: two “universal” buttons, one of which by default controlled navigation voice guidance, have disappeared from the steering wheel. Before, you could switch off the “intrusive lady” and ask for help only when needed. Now you have to listen to the advice all the time. At the same time, there are two unused buttons on the steering wheel.

Yes, they are reserved for adaptive cruise control. But does the distance to the vehicle in front really need to be changed that often? The idea being, “No, I’m 5 seconds too far from the car in front, let me get closer.”

Navigation: entering a destination

My first attempt was to enter the final destination. I chose the country, Poland, and typed “Katovice”. No results. Impressive. I typed “Katovi”. No results.

Now a remark. CCC searched directly, in parallel with text input. If I typed text and suddenly got 0 results, I understood that the last letter was invalid. NBT EVO starts the search only after input is completed (after pressing OK), so I don’t know when, or whether, I have made a mistake in any letter.

In CCC, names of cities and places could also be entered not only in their “original” language but in “foreign” ones too, for example Warszava, Varšava, Warsaw.

When I realized I couldn’t deal with the input, I opened Waze. Waze immediately understood my “Katovice” and said it could take me to “KatoWice”. My mistake was obvious: in Polish it is written with W, not V.

I entered “Katowice”. Here are the results:

Next results:

What, please? Why am I being offered places like Katowa and Katowicka street (not even Katowice; I assume there are a million places like that) instead of the direct match on the first line?

I scrolled to the next results:

Scrolling lower. What, please?

And more:

And more:

Katowice is listed some 15 times. Then it is listed another 15 times, with a distance of +1 km:

And more:

In total, Katowice is shown 30+ times among 50 results, with these 2 distances. What kind of circus is this? Results like these are also displayed:

And again the old story: CCC handled both Katovice and Katowice and returned them as one result.

Even if BMW were too “lazy” to combine maps in different languages, there should be at least some elementary things:

  • Linguistic substitutions. People typically enter destination names from auditory memory, so variants such as “KatoVice/KatoWice” or “BiAlistok/BiElistok/BiAlistoCk” should be recognized.
  • Tolerance for wrong letters in the input. For example, assume every 5th letter could be wrong, both linguistically and by ±1 position on the wheel/alphabet (a driver can skip a letter when using the wheel while driving).
  • Filtering or grouping of duplicate names, inputs and results. 30+ identical results is not even funny anymore. It is a shame.

NOTHING of this is present in the 5th (!) generation of BMW navigation. Gentlemen, how much do you charge for this product? 2000 EUR? 2500 EUR?

I’ll say it honestly: during this trip, for part of the time I determined my direction by following the sun (!), and later I was amused by how NBT “performed”. An epic experience.

50 shades of red

This time the interior is red, so a correction: 50 shades of red. You don’t have to be colorblind to see that the shade of the interior differs between parts, and you can’t blame cleaning agents or anything like that. Check the quality of the interior while you are at it. A pleasure to enjoy! This is a car in the 60,000 EUR price category. Most of the part mismatches could be solved at the design stage. Even if the production equipment is so inaccurate that it can’t hold 1 mm tolerances…

Here the part is not “matched”; it is “slightly” a different shade.

See how these parts “pass” each other. Perfectly! Here it goes in, there it goes out. Three parts, 3 shades, and textures of red!

And here is a design masterpiece: anodized aluminum, polished aluminum, matt plastic, piano-finish imitation (or whatever it is), plastic again, then a piece of rubber. Then two parts, each in a different shade of plastic, with a different surface texture. And then there are the gaps and cracks:

Start/Stop indicator

Now briefly on ergonomics. In front of the Start/Stop switch-off indicator there are two obstacles (sounds cool, no?): the steering wheel and the wiper stalk. At the same time, this indicator is NOT duplicated in the instrument cluster or on the NBT screen. Maybe BMW employees would like to demonstrate how they themselves check which mode the Start/Stop system is in? I would love to see it. This is not the first such fail. A very similar situation already existed with the steering wheel heating on E6x and F1x cars. It was different in each of them, but “successful” enough in both.

Do you see the Start/Stop switch and indicator? No? But they are there.

Accelerator pedal

Maybe I am special. Maybe my feet are different from other people’s. If so, please let me know. The problem is that the accelerator pedal is “too light”, meaning its resistance is too low. I don’t have to press it, but when driving at a steady speed I have to strain my leg to avoid pressing the pedal too far. Yes, I understand that shoes differ, lighter and heavier, and that seating positions differ. I’m 1.90 m tall, with the seat in its lowest and furthest-back position. I agree that such a “light” pedal also gives the feeling that the car is “light” and accelerates “without any strain”. I remember that for the first electronic accelerator pedals the manufacturer built in back-pressure curves, so they were obviously thinking about this aspect. My subjective feeling is that the resistance has been reduced with each new generation of cars.

The situation is better in “Comfort” mode, because then the DME changes the curve so that the low and medium load range is “stretched”. But then the leg gets tired too.

Someone will say: use the cruise control. Yes and no. On longer drives there are often stretches where cruise control is not a comfortable solution, because the speed of the traffic flow keeps changing. Another aspect is that using cruise control does not improve traffic safety at all: the driver significantly “switches off” from driving, and reaction time becomes longer.

In my opinion, the fundamental solution would be either an adaptive pedal “stiffness” or at least a setting in the NBT menu. One servo motor, one spring, one motor driver. Cost: several EUR. Too expensive!

Sound system

This is the part that “makes my ears bleed” in all kinds of BMW models, including expensive setups with BO, L7 and other miracles. The F32 is no exception. There will be a separate entry on this, but in short, such a pathetic level shows disrespect for the car’s users. It’s that simple.

Yes, you can object that my requirements are higher than those of the average user. Indeed, starting with my first car, all of mine have had custom installations over the last 15+ years, SQ competition-level installs. But now, from the position of a simple user, I would like to know how it comes that cars priced 3 to 5+ times lower have much better sound. BMW, how come?

BEYOND THE FAULT CODE

A clearer picture.
A better next step.

Get in touch
Enlarged technical image
Open original image