Select a technical image to view it in detail.

Several years ago I wrote an entry about a local company that had bought a piezo injector cleaning module for its injector cleaning stand. I was their first customer and tested the equipment with 10 different injectors, some working correctly and some with well-known defects. After cleaning, the leakage found in some of them disappeared on repeat testing. The first experience was not excellent, but I had no great expectations (the reasons are below).
Since then I have collected data and experience from several hundred customers, at least, in different European countries, so I am writing a second part. Unfortunately, the conclusions are pretty harsh.
Why stand diagnostics rarely finds real problems
Only in rare cases do these stands indicate a problem. There are several reasons.
- Room temperature. Tests are performed at room temperature. Piezo injector leakage often shows up only at low temperatures, and such defects cannot be found at room temperature. The same applies to injectors that leak only when hot, since the working temperature of an injector reaches 100 °C and more.
- Test pressure. The ASNU stand, for example, tests at 5 bar, while rail pressure on N43/N53/N54/N63 engines reaches 200 bar. A test pressure 40 times lower will not reveal injector problems, and only totally worn injectors will leak under such conditions. At 5 bar, the true flow rate and the shape of the spray cannot be evaluated either.
- Wrong injection profiles. The more advanced and widely available Carbon Zapp stands test piezo injectors with N54 injection profiles. These differ completely from N43/N53 engines. One example is idle rail pressure: 50 bar on the N54 versus 100…150…200 bar on N43/N53. Carbon Zapp does not evaluate injector flow in short-opening modes (100…200 µs pulses), yet these modes are used in the most critical conditions, idle and low torque. For shorter pulses (Carbon Zapp offers a 240 µs test) it also uses a lower test pressure, 180 bar instead of 200 bar, which again does not match real conditions.
- No spray angle measurement. No stand is designed to measure the angle of the injected spray accurately. BMW’s DI method (used only by BMW) ignites the fuel at the moment of injection, so the fuel must pass right next to the spark. If the fuel is even slightly farther from the spark plug, it will not ignite. If the fuel hits the plug and floods it, a misfire is guaranteed. None of the stands detects this.
- No atomization assessment. The main operating mode of N43 and N53 engines is stratified charge, where the fuel is ignited directly after injection. It has no time to mix with air in the combustion chamber, so atomization is very important. Atomization describes whether the fuel leaves the injector as micro-droplets (a fine fog) or as a stream. It can only be judged visually, and that is unrealistic for such short openings, on the order of ten-thousandths of a second, because human vision is far too slow. No stand has a very high-speed camera (hundreds of thousands of frames per second), and such a camera costs a huge amount of money.
- Sporadic defects. Piezo injectors most often have intermittent defects, at least in 50% of cases. The fault appears and disappears, and even a perfect stand would not catch it.
Contamination of the cleaning system
There is one more fundamental problem: the cleaning fluid and the cleanliness of the whole system. The maximum allowed leakage opening of a piezo injector is a few fractions of a micrometer, so the slightest dirt, impurity or foreign body causes enormous problems.
The injectors put on the stand are used, clogged or leaking ones. Dirt from them enters the cleaning system and can be carried back into the next injectors tested. The cleaning liquid is obviously not replaced after each injector, because the cost would be unreasonable. The whole system, including pipes and storage container, becomes contaminated. This is a fundamental problem for cleaning and testing these capricious injectors.
How the stands are used in practice
Most users of these stands do not even know how to use them properly. In at least 50% of cases the reference data for the injectors was entered incorrectly, for example with a very wide allowed range. As a result, even damaged injectors “successfully” passed all tests. In practically no case did the service staff draw any conclusions themselves or give any additional information, even when the test results were completely unsatisfactory.
In many cases injector performance got much worse after cleaning, with a pronounced flow through the injector in the closed position. In at least one of three such cleaning cases, all injectors had to be replaced because the leakage after the procedure had become a catastrophe. Evidently the cleaning liquid was contaminated with impurities that lodged in the injector nozzle.
Among the many cases sent to me, I could not confirm a single one in which the laboratory test results even approximately correlated with the DME’s own measurements in real operating conditions. The situation really is that harsh.
What the DME already measures
For N43/N53 engines, INPA can show the following injector parameters, measured by the DME in real operating conditions:
- Injector flow measurements in homogeneous mode (chemical test results) in different segments, also with a cold engine.
- Injector flow corrections in stratified charge (chemical test results). Atomization quality is detected separately.
- Injector leakage in the closed position in stratified charge (mechanical efficiency test results).
- Corrections of the injector delay parameter in both homogeneous and stratified charge modes (mechanical efficiency test results).
- Mechanical efficiency of each cylinder at idle, in both homogeneous and stratified charge modes.
- The delay and flow correction data currently applied to each injector.
- Electrical parameters of each injector, including charge/discharge energy and the voltage reached during the opening period.
- Error message records with detailed freeze-frame data showing the conditions and the kind of problem the injector experienced.
- Misfire density data (available via OBD Mode 6), which also allows the spray of the injector to be evaluated.
Several tens of different parameters are available for each injector, along with live data showing the performance of each injector (cylinder) in the exact operating modes.
Conclusion
I categorically do NOT recommend cleaning these injectors, and I do NOT recommend testing them on these stands. Besides wasting money, you risk contaminating your injectors with impurities from the test circuit. My advice is to keep away from these stands.
What to do instead
- Have professional diagnostics performed, with the data of all injectors analyzed.
- Replace the injectors that diagnostics identified as faulty.
- Carry out the necessary service procedures: injector coding and engine re-adaptation.
- Evaluate the situation after the repair.
Note: on N43/N53 engines, full stratified charge functionality should be restored first, because many injector parameters are measured precisely in stratified charge mode.
Also read: fuel additives. Want to try?