Skip to content
Shop
Explore

INDEPENDENT BMW ENGINE EXPERTISE

An excellent injectors

N43 / N53 · NOXEM · DIAGNOSTICS

Select a technical image to view it in detail.

Quite often we hear that the state of BMW-specific repair is critical, and that BMW engine and diagnostics specialists are in short supply. I agree. But sometimes the car owners are the ones to blame, and this entry is another example.

I have said many times on my blog: do not buy “restored”, “repaired” or “cleaned” piezo injectors. They can be neither cleaned nor repaired. Still, some BMW owners do the opposite. The reasons vary: hoping for luck, wanting to save money, or not believing the “pessimistic” diagnostics specialist. Only the owner knows the real reason. This entry shows what the diagnostic data look like when injectors have been “repaired” this way.

The case

The owner of a BMW with an N53 engine came to me. He had installed “restored” injectors bought from a large, well-known German company. I will not name it, because I cannot verify the facts with 100% certainty.

The engine sometimes vibrates, and there are misfires. The NOx system has been repaired and works, and Stratified charge is in use, so everything should be perfect.

I received the diagnostic data. Incorrect values are marked in red.

Adaptation and fuel mixture

The first suspicious symptom: the DME switched the engine to Mapped mode at 80 °C. At the higher temperature it had detected incorrect injector performance.

The bank adaptation by temperature segment confirms that in the last two segments both banks had problems with fuel mixture stability.

Next, the basic fuel mixture data. The control probes of both banks show a rich mixture, and the Offset LTFT of bank 1 points to leaking injectors.

Right after the engine starts, the injector problem of bank 1 is already visible.

The NOx sensor also confirms the mixture problems. The average mixture really is rich, and the exhaust temperature is strongly increased. This means a large part of the fuel is burning in the CO catalytic converters, so they are being overloaded and damaged.

Injector tests

Here are the chemical efficiency tests of the injectors in Homogeneous mode. The deviations from the ideal for injectors No.2, 3 and 4 are huge.

Here are the injector leakage test results at idle in Stratified charge.

In this menu I marked every injector test value as incorrect, because the picture is complete chaos. It is hard to find an injector that does not leak or does not have an atomization problem. For example, the injector of cylinder No.2 leaks very strongly, while the atomization of injector No.3 is critically bad: it pours the fuel out rather than injecting it. The injector of cylinder No.5 also leaks strongly.

Here are the chemical test results for the injectors in Stratified charge at partial load. Injectors No.2 and No.3 have flow rate problems.

Here are the live data of the injectors in Homogeneous mode. Both Offset and flow rate corrections are applied to the injectors, and the parameter scatter between them has increased. Injectors No.3 and No.4 have a reduced flow rate.

Cylinder efficiency and lambda

Here is the mechanical efficiency of the cylinders.

This is a complete crash in both banks, and it is not a case of just one leaking injector per bank. Almost all the injectors have problems. Injectors No.1 to 3 leak, and injectors No.4 and No.5 also have problems.

The injectors leak so widely that even the lambda values of both banks in Stratified charge are strongly reduced.

Finally, the error message list.

At idle in Stratified charge, the mechanical efficiency of cylinders No.2 and No.3 increased even when the injector opening time was reduced by 50%. So the injectors leaked so strongly that the injected fuel quantity was at least 3 to 5 times larger than it should have been.

Cost and the seller’s response

This example shows that ALL the injectors belong in the trash can. Unfortunately, the owner wasted 1000 to 1500 EUR on these injectors and their installation. Worse, the whole exhaust system has suffered badly. If the problem is not solved immediately, he can expect at least 3000 EUR in additional costs.

The owner took my diagnostic report to the injector seller and made a complaint. The seller offered a “bonus”: a free “diagnosis” on their injector stand, and replacement of the “defective” injectors with others, also “restored”.

This offer shows the seller’s complete incompetence, for these reasons:

  • Injector stand tests are performed at room temperature, while in real conditions injectors work at -30 to 120 °C.
  • Laboratory tests cannot evaluate fuel atomization.
  • Laboratory tests cannot reveal sporadic defects.
  • Laboratory tests cannot reproduce other real conditions, such as changes in rail pressure.

Such laboratory tests are completely useless.

The DME live and test data confirm countless problems with all the injectors. There is no point in trying to find a usable injector in this pile of garbage.

Is there anyone else who would like to try “restored” injectors?

BEYOND THE FAULT CODE

A clearer picture.
A better next step.

Get in touch
Enlarged technical image
Open original image