Select a technical image to view it in detail.
The “Secret Customer” Revisited
This entry is a little different from my usual ones, but possibly even more interesting.
Several years ago I ran an experiment I called “the secret customer”. Going incognito as far as possible, I visited several BMW repair specialists and evaluated their work. One of those cases was only partially successful, and I paid it no particular attention until yesterday.
The first visit
I call that visit unsuccessful because the specialist claimed to be busy. He also said he was very familiar with N43/N53 engines, but that they are so complicated that diagnostics take far more than half an hour or an hour. I would have to leave the car with him for at least a day. Otherwise it was no problem.
Then he suddenly found time for a long conversation. He told me he regularly “deals” with these complicated engines, and that there are even project cars injecting gas under huge pressure through these piezo injectors. He came across as very knowledgeable. I even left positive feedback on his Facebook page, saying he knew what he was talking about. I should admit this was a unique case.
What changed yesterday
Yesterday this specialist sent me diagnostics data on behalf of one of his customers. The car has an N43 engine, the very engine he is “very familiar” with. I had also defined precisely which information was required. In my opinion this was a very simple task, the simplest step in the whole job. What could go wrong?
No freeze-frame
I received an error code, but no freeze-frame. How is that possible? Anyone who knows what a freeze-frame is either skips the plain list of codes or uses it only as a checklist so that no fault is forgotten, because the freeze-frame holds much more of the information needed. Strange? Even more than strange.
There had been other fault codes earlier, but all of them were deleted, apparently without saving their freeze-frames. That does not sound very professional.
The engine was not at operating conditions
The next oddities appeared when I checked the basic engine data:

And the NOx sensor menu:

The engine is clearly not warmed up to working temperature, unless the specialist considers 66 °C to be working temperature. The exhaust temperature also shows that the car had not been driven, or at least that driving had not been simulated. Why does this matter? A specialist who knew the subject would know that these two conditions are critical, because:
- The DME commands the NOx sensor to switch to Online mode and start sending data.
- The DME tries to activate stratified charge and to update the adaptations for injector atomization and dripping.
Evidently this specialist is unaware of this, so it is no surprise that the NOx sensor is Offline and its menu is useless. The fault list contains a code for exactly this sensor (30A4), so meeting these conditions is critical for this diagnosis.
The wrong loader
Then came some very strange menus, for example:



Why did the specialist send these? The answer is simple: his computer has loader 1.001 installed, as the top left corner of each screenshot confirms, not 2.023. The difference is fundamental. The old loader lacks everything related to the injectors, both their data and their adaptations. The injectors are the most capricious component of these engines and the cause of most of their problems. It makes no sense to touch these engines at all without injector data.
That data holds a huge amount of valuable information, more than 20 (!) data positions per injector:
- Live injection data.
- Flow-rate data applied to the injectors.
- Electrical parameters of the injectors: energy supplied and voltage reached during injection.
- Results of the chemical tests of the injectors in Homogeneous mode: the last test, cold-engine tests, and an injector flow-rate test in two modes, low and high load.
- Injector atomization and dripping tests, and chemical efficiency tests of the cylinders at partial load during injection in Stratified charge mode.
- DME status (learnbits) showing which bank tests and injector measurements have been completed successfully.
NONE of this is visible in loader 1.001.
I have several things to say about this.
First, the requirement for loader 2.023 is stated directly above the list of required data, and the link to the necessary files is in the same place.
Second, how can a specialist who regularly works with these engines not have the right software version? INPA and this loader are the only software that supplies these data, so “I use another tool” is not an excuse. Evidently he has never once checked the injector data. So how does he repair these engines? Does he replace all the injectors? The engines?
Third, even if he has never checked the injector data, he should have noticed that the list lacks the relevant options. Pressing the corresponding key combinations, such as Shift+F6, does nothing at all. That should have prompted some reaction from him. In fact, the situation is even worse. Let us go back to the images he sent instead of the injector data.
Screenshots that tell nothing

This is the cylinder switch-off menu. It is a test block: pressing the appropriate Fx key switches off the injector of that particular cylinder. What use is it as an image? None.

This menu allows or prohibits different injection methods, with the choices at the top of the page. What use is it as an image? None. This, too, is a test block.

And for dessert, this menu, a test module for the Lambda probes. A few remarks on it:
- It works, and is intended, for the 6-cylinder N52, N53 and N54 engines. The customer’s car has an N43.
- Its purpose is to identify swapped Lambda probes. In a 2+2 configuration (wideband plus control probes), it checks that every probe is connected in the right place. For this you press F1 and watch the test bars during the test.
In this screenshot most of the bars are empty. That is no surprise: nobody pressed F1, so the test was not run, and it could not have been run anyway because the engine has only 2 or 3 probes. This image, too, is completely useless.
Conclusion
What do I conclude from receiving such images? That the person who sent them has not the slightest idea what he is looking at. Like a robot, he sends everything the computer shows. So how can a specialist who claims to work regularly with these engines understand nothing of the data the manufacturer’s diagnostic tool displays?
The answer is simple: he is a specialist only in talking. I admit that I, too, fell for his talking skills.
The moral of this entry is to be very critical when evaluating the abilities of specialists. Do not believe nice talk. And if your diagnostics specialist ever sends me diagnostic data and you receive remarks like these about it, draw the appropriate conclusions.