Skip to content
Shop
Explore

INDEPENDENT BMW ENGINE EXPERTISE

F10/11. How BMW hide problems

N43 / N53 · NOXEM · DIAGNOSTICS

In this entry I summarize briefly how the problems of the NOx system are hidden in the second-generation DME (MSD87; F10/F11).

This time I start with information that BMW dealer centers cannot get. I end with notes on INPA, which dealer centers are not allowed to use.

References to ISTA D/+ are based on versions up to the August 2019 release, although these engines have not received an update for a long time. I also note where the second generation differs from the first-generation DME (MSD80, N43/N53 engines). References to INPA correspond to MSD87 for the N54, loader 3.700.

Problems the system hides

1. Sulfur contamination of the NOx catalytic converter is hidden. No error message exists to identify it. By 50,000–100,000 km, at least 90% of vehicles have been affected at least once, and for more than half it is a fundamental problem. Because of it, the engine does not use stratified charge. 2. Insufficient performance of the NOx catalytic converter is hidden. An error message for insufficient catalyst performance exists, but in practice it is almost never set. The problem affects nearly all cars at 150,000–200,000 km. Beyond 200,000 km the NOx system of 99% of cars stops functioning. The engine then no longer uses stratified charge, even when driving conditions are ideal for it (long drives at a steady speed above 110 km/h). 3. The NOx sensor’s self-calibration problem is hidden, deliberately. This very common fault means the sensor never confirms readiness and never starts sending live data. A few minutes after switching on (5–10 minutes), stratified charge is turned off and is not used for the rest of the driving session. No error message is recorded. This hides the underlying problem: the NOx sensor lasts only a few tens of thousands of kilometers.

What ISTA D/+ no longer shows

So that nobody asks unnecessary questions, the following information is not available in ISTA D/+ (it was available in the first generation):

  • Performance mode (homogeneous or stratified charge).
  • Contamination of the NOx catalytic converter.
  • NOx sensor status (Expecting Dev point; All signals OK, etc.).
  • NOx content and lambda as measured by the NOx sensor.
  • Exhaust temperature.

Diagnosing these complicated engines is made even harder because the following is also missing:

  • Offset-type LTFT.
  • Lambda values of the wideband probes (only voltage is shown).
  • Integrators.
  • Knock (detonation) sensor readings.

In addition, cylinder cut-off in ISTA D/+ does not work. When any cylinder is disconnected, other data can no longer be observed.

Limitations in INPA

INPA has its own problems:

  • Integrators are not visible in the fuel mixture menu.
  • The NOx sensor menu does not work.
  • Test data for the chemical efficiency of the injectors and the mechanical efficiency of the cylinders are not available. The live data of the injector corrections are available, which is some consolation.

Conclusion

Without INPA the situation would be close to hopeless. I really do not understand how a dealer center can help cars with these engines. More precisely, I do understand why dealer centers cannot help when these engines do not work as intended.

BEYOND THE FAULT CODE

A clearer picture.
A better next step.

Get in touch
Enlarged technical image
Open original image