Skip to content
Shop
Explore

INDEPENDENT BMW ENGINE EXPERTISE

Suspicious injector

N43 / N53 · NOXEM · DIAGNOSTICS

Select a technical image to view it in detail.

On June 1, 2023, an owner of an N43 engine bought a “new” injector from a dealer in Germany. The injector does not look new, and the owner’s remark that it is refurbished is quite appropriate. He sent me some images of it.

It is no secret anymore that “new” injectors are now refurbished ones. But I noticed some other suspicious details.

What looks wrong with this injector

First, someone has cleaned the injector. Has the manufacturer started doing this? As far as I have seen, no: injectors from the manufacturer or refurbisher still arrive dirty and rusty. I have described how dealers themselves have started cleaning injectors (read here). The new owner, however, did not voice any objections about the condition, so the injector was cleaned beforehand.

Second, check the manufacturing date. This injector was manufactured exactly 7(!) months ago.

I can understand an injector taking a month or two to travel from the manufacturer to the buyer. But SEVEN months? I don’t believe it. Injectors are still heavily backordered, so there is no way one sat in a warehouse for seven months. Nor does it have to travel around the world, since the manufacturer is located close to Germany.

How a used injector could end up as “new”

Taken together, these two points suggest to me that the injector is very probably not only refurbished but also used. You might ask how that could be possible. Why not? It is possible, and there are several ways it could happen.

1. The dealer installed it and then took it back out. The dealer who sold the injector may have installed it in an engine earlier. After some time (the customer’s test drives, several weeks in the queue for repeated “diagnostics”, a few more repair attempts), it became clear that the problem was not solved, or that it had come back. After the car owner complained about unjustified repair costs, the injector was removed, cleaned and put back on the shelf. None of the employees would cover the cost of a faulty repair or diagnosis.

Faulty diagnostics happen every day at a dealership, for many reasons:

  • no injector data or INPA data is available;
  • TIS defines an incorrect repair sequence;
  • the dealer does not analyze live data (the manufacturer does this in a PUMA case, which is not opened without an exceptional reason).

It is also possible that the injector was replaced during the warranty period even though the dealer did not believe it was the culprit. It may have been replaced simply because TIS says that all injectors of the bank, or even of the whole engine, have to be replaced.

2. A customer or partner returned it. A good customer, meaning one who is allowed to return purchased spare parts, or a cooperation partner may have sent it back. The partner could be another dealer or a seller outside the dealer network. Returning a part with such limited availability is strange, of course. But managers and warehouse workers handle hundreds or even thousands of parts and orders every day. They are not interested in specific details and cannot remember them all.

The most important point is that we do not know why the injector went back to the warehouse. It may have been returned because of faulty diagnostics, or it may really have had a problem. The problem may also have appeared because the customer used the wrong type of fuel or added fuel additives.

So on top of the known problem (gambling with the quality and longevity of refurbished injectors), there is a new one: the unknown “life” of the injector over the past half year.

I would not buy such an injector. I would ask to exchange it for a “new” refurbished one.

A comparison: an injector with a plausible history

To back up my statements, here is another example:

This injector was manufactured on March 21, 2023, only TWO months earlier. In that time it has already traveled farther than the German dealer’s warehouse. It was sent to Poland, and from the Polish dealer’s warehouse it was sold or sent to an online seller. That is a logical timeframe, in my opinion. This time I believe the injector came from VDO and is “newly” refurbished.

BEYOND THE FAULT CODE

A clearer picture.
A better next step.

Get in touch
Enlarged technical image
Open original image