Skip to content
Shop
Explore

INDEPENDENT BMW ENGINE EXPERTISE

Spark plugs. Part 2

N43 / N53 · NOXEM · DIAGNOSTICS

Thanks to Jan for the information and pictures. While replacing the spark plugs, he noticed some details that looked suspicious, and with good reason. He had acted conscientiously: he chose the plugs from those recommended in the official catalog, with no free interpretation. So what could go wrong?

Let me take it in order.

The symptoms

In the first part of this topic I stated that only one spark plug model is intended for N43/N53 engines: NGK ZKBR7A-HTU.

Quite often, though, there were (and still are) engines that ran very unsatisfactorily. The injectors, spark plugs, ignition coils and other parts had been replaced, and still the engines could not run in stratified charge mode. They shivered and had group misfires. The cars practically “lived” in workshops, where the specialists drove them a little and then did yet another repair, after which nothing had changed or improved.

In all of these cases I found that Bosch spark plugs were installed. After they were replaced with NGK, the engines were suddenly “repaired”.

Bosch and NGK compared

Jan sent images comparing the NGK and Bosch spark plugs. The Bosch plug is supposedly a 1:1 analog, if we can trust the seller and manufacturer.

[[[KEEP1]]](https://bimmerprofs.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/NGK_vs_Bosch_1.jpg)

Bosch spark plug on the left, NGK on the right.

Look at the air gap of the NGK plug. It is huge. The plug is used and its central electrode is slightly worn, but the gap is impressive anyway.

[[[KEEP2]]](https://bimmerprofs.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/NGK_vs_Bosch_2.jpg)

Bosch spark plug on top, NGK on the bottom. This is a perfect picture: even the model numbers are visible, so there is no doubt about identification.

Here you can clearly see that the NGK plug is “longer”, by several mm. You can also see that its air gap is significantly larger than that of the Bosch plug.

[[[KEEP3]]](https://bimmerprofs.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/NGK_vs_Bosch_3.jpg)

NGK spark plug on the left, Bosch on the right.

Comments are almost redundant. These are completely different spark plugs, and again the difference in air gap is huge.

This is what a new NGK ZKBR7A-HTU looks like:

[[[KEEP4]]](https://bimmerprofs.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/right_spark_plug.png)

The air gap is significantly larger than the diameter of the central electrode. On the Bosch plug it is less than half of the central electrode’s diameter.

The NGK plug is intended for stratified charge, while the Bosch plug is intended only for engines running in homogeneous mode. The placement and diameter of the central electrode are also fundamentally different.

With the NGK plug, whichever side electrode “works”, the spark is concentrated at the center of the plug, so the fuel jet from the injector is ignited equally well. With the Bosch plug, the spark can appear in 3 different places, each in a separate part of the “space”, depending on which side electrode is in use. If the spark forms on the side closest to the injector, the fuel ignites. If the electrode farther from the injector works, it does not. The small air gap also causes problems, because the spark is too weak.

Why so many owners installed the wrong plug

How could so many BMW owners end up choosing the wrong spark plugs? The answer is simple: Bosch published incorrect information in its official catalog.

You can check it yourself at http://www.bosch-automotive-catalog.com.

[[[KEEP5]]](https://bimmerprofs.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/bosch_fail_1.png)

For example, choose an E60 with an N53B30 engine:

[[[KEEP6]]](https://bimmerprofs.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/bosch_fail_2.png)

The result: the catalog says this Bosch spark plug fits.

Now look at the detailed information:

[[[KEEP7]]](https://bimmerprofs.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/bosch_spark_plug_2.png)

The air gap is 0.9 mm. For stratified-charge engines it should be about twice as large. The diameter of the central electrode is also wrong: it has to be much smaller, meaning a thinner electrode.

First conclusion: the one analog listed in the Bosch catalog CANNOT be used in N43/N53 engines.

The NGK catalog has errors too

Now let’s see what NGK says about its own plugs. This is a fragment of the 2016/2017 catalog:

[[[KEEP8]]](https://bimmerprofs.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/NGK_catalogue.png)

[[[KEEP9]]](https://bimmerprofs.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/NGK_fail_2.png)

What? Are these plugs with an increased air gap also supposed to fit N52 engines, which use “regular” spark plugs? And that is not even counting the mistakenly stated air gap (0.8 mm).

Let’s check the fitment against Realoem data:

[[[KEEP10]]](https://bimmerprofs.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/NGK_fail_1.png)

N52 engines are not listed there, which is logical. The “regular” spark plugs are not interchangeable with the ZKBR7A-HTU High Energy plugs, quite apart from other differences such as size and heat range. If you installed ZKBR7A-HTU in an N52 engine, the ignition coils would be damaged very quickly and the engine would have mass misfires.

According to Realoem, these are the spark plugs intended for N52N engines:

[[[KEEP11]]](https://bimmerprofs.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/N52N_spark_plugs.png)

And this is how they look. They are completely different in size and have one side electrode:

[[[KEEP12]]](https://bimmerprofs.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/N52N_spark_plugs_2.png)

Conclusion No. 2: the catalogs of BOTH leading manufacturers (Bosch and NGK) contain gross mistakes.

Conclusion No. 3: obviously, you can rely ONLY on BMW databases.

What the wrong plugs do: misfire counters

Finally, what happens when Bosch “analog” spark plugs are installed in an N43 engine? This is a typical situation. Here is the misfire data after a test session of 10 to 15 minutes:

[[[KEEP13]]](https://bimmerprofs.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/bosch_fail_3.png)

The misfire counters of the current driving session are 7/16/1/12, so cylinders 1, 2 and 4 have serious problems.

The long-term misfire counters are 2/2/0/1. Multiply these values by 10 to make them easier to interpret. On average, then, previous sessions had around 20/20/0/10 events each. Not all misfires are registered by the system, and not every one adds a full unit (usually it is 0.X). So we must conclude that during each driving session the engine shivered hundreds of times.

This is after switching to NGK spark plugs, following a 30 km test drive:

[[[KEEP14]]](https://bimmerprofs.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/NGK_sparks_installed.jpg)

All long-term misfire counters are 0. That means that during the last 5 to 10 sessions the number of misfires was small, below 5 events in each. The short-term counters show 1 event in cylinder 1 and 0 in the others. This is a perfect result.

How to use misfire counters

Cylinder 3 deserves attention here. Even with the Bosch plug it worked correctly, with misfire counters close to 0. This is very interesting. I assume the causes are the following:

  • The injector of this cylinder sprays the fuel in a slightly wider bundle, so the fuel gets closer to the spark plug.
  • The adaptations may be completely wrong, because all the other cylinders were misfiring. The mixture would then be significantly richer in this cylinder than in the others, so it ignites much better.

BEYOND THE FAULT CODE

A clearer picture.
A better next step.

Get in touch
Enlarged technical image
Open original image