Skip to content
Shop
Explore

INDEPENDENT BMW ENGINE EXPERTISE

The meaning of a correct decision

N43 / N53 · NOXEM · DIAGNOSTICS

Select a technical image to view it in detail.

In this entry I want to show once more how much depends on making the right decision. The “pain” here is relatively small: about EUR 500 lost, plus wasted time. But if the problem is not solved now (about EUR 400 of additional investment), the costs can grow considerably in the near future.

The case

The owner of a BMW with an N53 engine contacted me and sent his diagnostic data. It was a classic case of a damaged NOx system, with every possible fault message for the NOx sensor. The sensor could not reach Online mode. I had no illusions about the NOx catalytic converter either; it was unlikely to be in better shape. The car had more than 200,000 km on it and was over 10 years old. It had been driven with a damaged NOx sensor for a long time, most likely the last 8 years, since the manufacturer’s warranty ended.

I explained to the owner that the NOx system can be repaired in two ways:

  • Replace the complete system, meaning both the sensor and the catalytic converter.
  • Install an emulator.

The emulator saves money because it avoids replacing the expensive NOx catalytic converter. The owner asked again whether an OEM NOx sensor alone was really not a solution. I gave him a more detailed justification, including links to entries on my blog that explain all the technical nuances. Everything seemed clear.

The repair that went wrong

Some time later the owner wrote that he had repaired the car, but something was not right. The vibrations had not disappeared and fuel consumption was still increased.

One sentence in his message caught my attention: “From your attachment, I decided to replace the old sensor with the original new NOx sensor (+adaptation, etc…)” (the emphasis is the owner’s own).

What? Why?

The owner asked me to evaluate the result of the repair, so I looked at the live data. There were no fault messages in the DME fault memory. The NOx sensor data confirms that the sensor is transmitting:

All the values the sensor sends are reasonably plausible, and I have no doubt that the sensor really is OEM and really is new.

Injector learnbits

Here are the injector learnbits:

The learnbits marked in red belong to stratified charge operation, and they should be colored. Uncolored learnbits mean that the DME is not using stratified charge.

As a test, here is the view of the injector data in stratified charge:

This confirms it. The DME has not run in stratified charge at idle even once for long enough to measure the injectors, which typically takes a minute or two.

Why the DME avoids stratified charge

There are three possible reasons for this behavior:

  • Misfires. In that case, at least fault 3104 would be stored.
  • Weak performance of the CO catalytic converters in stratified charge. In that case, faults 2A26 and 2A27 would be stored.
  • Weak performance of the NOx catalytic converter.

With a very weak NOx catalytic converter, the DME switches stratified charge on briefly but turns it off again quickly, because it detects a very high content of nitrogen oxides in the exhaust. Over a longer period the DME becomes certain that the NOx catalytic converter is damaged and stores fault 30E9, which disables stratified charge permanently.

If the DME does not use stratified charge, it does not perform a number of important injector measurements. Vibrations, misfires, and an overloaded (and quickly damaged) CO catalytic converter are guaranteed consequences.

Conclusion

Unfortunately, my verdict of a completely damaged NOx catalytic converter was correct, and the owner’s decision to fit an OEM NOx sensor was wrong. The repair made no sense. Worse, the vibrations continue, and so do the overloading and damage of the CO catalytic converters.

The moral of this entry: sometimes it is worth following the instructions.

BEYOND THE FAULT CODE

A clearer picture.
A better next step.

Get in touch
Enlarged technical image
Open original image