Skip to content
Shop
Explore

INDEPENDENT BMW ENGINE EXPERTISE

B58. VANOS repair. Part 2

N43 / N53 · NOXEM · DIAGNOSTICS

Select a technical image to view it in detail.

I thank the whole team: the service manager, the mechanics who repaired my car, and the manager who fought for my warranty rights. This time I have only good things to say. I left the car and keys, and two days later I got both back. It was that simple.

Now to the technical side.

Symptoms

  • Jerky acceleration and jerky torque maintenance, especially pronounced with a partially warmed-up engine.
  • A harsh reaction of the engine to changes in the requested torque.
  • Uneven idle.

There were no entries in the DME fault memory. The “old” VANOS test passed successfully, but the new VANOS test (available in ISTA since the beginning of 2022) failed.

Old and new VANOS tests

Both tests repeat their sequence several times.

The old VANOS test:

  • With the VANOS valve closed, the camshaft position and its jitter are checked against the reference position.
  • The camshaft is moved to the actual position, and the exact position and its jitter are checked.

The new VANOS test:

  • With the VANOS valve closed, the camshaft position and its jitter are checked against the reference position.
  • The camshaft is moved to the actual position, and the actual position and its jitter are checked.
  • Additionally, the camshaft position is shifted by 40 degrees relative to the reference.

The permitted jitter and position deviation is ±5 degrees in both tests.

This 40-degree movement of the VANOS hub proved to be the critical step. It formally confirmed the problem and served as evidence for the dealer and the insurance company.

Results after the repair

Expert mode, VANOS, after the repair:

The image shows the requested and actual positions of both camshafts, both absolute and relative to the reference positions, together with the PWM values of the valves. All curves are perfectly stable.

The next image shows the PWM values of the valves, zoomed in.

To hold the camshaft positions stable, the valve PWM (axis 3) changes by only ±1 to 2 %. This is an excellent result.

Next, the requested and actual positions of the exhaust camshaft, which was the more problematic one, before and after the repair.

Before the repair:

After the repair:

Note the scale of the Y axis (axis 2). Before the repair, the exhaust camshaft (black curve) jittered by ±10 degrees. After the repair, this is down to ±1 degree, a tenfold reduction. In addition, the DME is no longer “twitching” the requested camshaft position.

I deliberately did not blur the VIN. It shows that the screenshots come from the same car and the same menu.

Idle after the repair:

The output of all cylinders (axis 2) is perfectly even. Mechanical efficiency is identical across cylinders, with differences of no more than ±1 to 2.

Valvetronic after the repair:

The blue curve is the rotor position of the control motor. It is stable, varying by only ±5 to 10 degrees (axis 3) over 20 seconds.

How the engine behaves now

  • The jerky acceleration has disappeared completely, and the reaction to the accelerator pedal is very soft.
  • The idle is of very high quality. Engine vibration is zero, even on a cold engine. Sitting in the car, you cannot tell whether the engine is running.
  • Fuel consumption is lower, especially noticeable at 70 to 100 km/h.

At last this engine works as it should, as the engine of a premium car should.

The removed solenoids

Interestingly, BMW AG asked the dealer to keep the solenoids from this repair.

I have to point out that the pin of one of the solenoids moved in jerks and showed significant wear. This is a substantial manufacturing failure. The sliding bearing should be made of a material that does not wear the pin. I assume this wear could be one of the causes, especially at higher mileage and even if the oil has been changed frequently.

Unfortunately, the old valves were thrown in the bin, and I had no chance to examine them. Here is a picture of a new valve:

The valve is about 12 mm in diameter, and its strainer is very, very fine. There is no doubt that this strainer will clog if the oil is not changed on time. The oscillating camshaft jitter before the repair points to exactly this kind of clogging, because it significantly slows the valve’s reaction time.

BEYOND THE FAULT CODE

A clearer picture.
A better next step.

Get in touch
Enlarged technical image
Open original image