This entry summarizes what I have learned from diagnosing and repairing several thousand N43/N53 engines.
The symptom
After Stratified charge has been restored, the engine shivers or jerks. This is a short-term unevenness in running, not a permanent, monotonous vibration.
A myth: the NOx system is to blame
Unqualified “specialists” sometimes blame the NOx system for this. Their reasoning is that the shivering disappears when the NOx sensor is disconnected or its operation is disabled in some other way, for example by connecting a non-working sensor.
This claim is wrong. The DME uses the NOx system for only one decision: whether to allow or restrict Stratified charge. When Stratified charge is allowed, the DME also uses the NOx data to decide how often the NOx catalytic converter must be cleaned (regeneration and desulfation sessions requested and performed). That is all. Every other decision is made by the DME itself, without any NOx data. This includes when and how much fuel to inject into each cylinder, how far to open the throttle, and when to ignite the mixture. So there is no such thing as a “more even” or “more uneven” sensor.
“Turning off” the NOx system can confirm only one thing: the engine has a problem specifically in Stratified charge mode. The NOx system is not at fault. On the contrary, it has ALLOWED Stratified charge, which means it is working correctly.
Typical causes of uneven running in Stratified charge mode
Spark plugs
Regular or frequent misfires in all cylinders often come from the wrong spark plugs. This is a relatively common problem. Many catalogs list Bosch plugs as equivalents, but they are not suitable for Stratified charge mode. More about spark plugs: here and here.
Fake NGK spark plugs also turn up, less often. Do not buy cheap spark plugs, even from a reliable wholesaler. It is worth buying them directly from a BMW dealer, and they will last longer.
Stratified charge needs considerably more spark energy to ignite the fuel than Homogeneous mode does. For this reason, Bosch plugs or worn-out NGK plugs may perform more or less correctly in Homogeneous mode and still fail in Stratified charge.
Ignition coils
I do not recommend Delphi ignition coils. More about their problems: here and here.
Use only the Bosch coil with code 0221504471. The catalogs also list another Bosch coil, a newer version presented as an equivalent. According to user reports, in several cases these coils caused mass misfires. They may have different parameters (a smaller transformation ratio) and are wrongly listed as full equivalents.
In Stratified charge mode the spark needs significantly more energy, three to four times as much as in Homogeneous mode. The quality of the ignition coils is therefore crucial. Coils that can ignite the mixture in Homogeneous mode may fail in Stratified charge.
Injectors
In Homogeneous mode, fuel is injected well before ignition. Even poorly injected fuel has enough time to mix with the air. If fuel hits the spark plug, the plug has time to dry. The mixture in the combustion chamber is rich enough to ignite.
In Stratified charge mode the situation is much harder. Fuel is injected and ignited almost at the same moment, so it has no time to mix with the air.
- The mixture at the spark must be rich enough to ignite. If the injector makes even a slight “mistake” and places the fuel slightly too far from the spark plug, the mixture will not light.
- If the fuel hits the spark plug, it will not ignite either, because the plug “drowns” and has no time to dry.
- The injector must deliver the fuel as a fine fog, because the fuel has no time to evaporate and mix with the air. This is the opposite of Homogeneous mode.
For all these reasons, an engine may run more or less acceptably in Homogeneous mode and still start to misfire in Stratified charge. More about injector problems: here. The third and fourth scenarios there are the relevant ones.
Note that a damaged injector does not stop causing harm if the engine runs only in Homogeneous mode. Even if no misfires are detected at the moment, the problems will show up:
- Poor atomization can melt a piston.
- Poorly burning fuel puts a heavy load on the CO catalytic converters, shortening their life or even damaging them quickly.
- An incorrect spray angle also makes the fuel burn badly.
Unfortunately, these engines have no operating mode that can ignore injector problems.
Error 3104 and software
Uneven running in Stratified charge is usually confirmed by error 3104. N53 engines, especially those with older SW/ZB releases, log error 3104 very readily, even on uneven roads. BMW AG tried several times to solve this problem (rough running and false 3104 errors) through software updates. More about that: here. The fundamental improvement is the DIRU upgrade, described here. A summary of the 3104 error is here.
Where to start
If the engine runs unevenly but the basics (ignition coils and spark plugs) are new, I suggest first checking the misfire counters. How to do that: here. The nuances specific to Stratified charge are described here.
If you follow these instructions step by step, the engine will run perfectly. There is no room for guessing or visual inspection. Looking at the ignition coils or injectors tells you nothing. Evaluate the injector data via INPA and the misfire counters via OBD Mode 6. Only technical data shows the actual situation.