Skip to content
Shop
Explore

INDEPENDENT BMW ENGINE EXPERTISE

Cold engine. Hiccup

N43 / N53 · NOXEM · DIAGNOSTICS

This entry covers an unpleasant symptom familiar to many N53 owners. It is known to be very common on N53 engines, and I have no confirmation of it on N43 engines.

The symptom

After a cold start, the engine shudders about 30 to 40 seconds later. The shudder can be pronounced or barely noticeable. If the car starts driving immediately after starting, I have not observed it.

This video shows a mild example of the problem (at the 46th second). The engine shudders at idle, then carries on as if nothing had happened. The DME fault memory contains no entries.

What the fuel mixture does

The next video was recorded at the same time as the first and shows the fuel mixture at the moment of the hiccup.

The only event at about the moment of the hiccup is the start of heating of the control probes. The mixture is correct throughout (Lambda around 1.00) and the integrators are stable. Nothing points to a mixture problem on either bank.

What else checks out

  • The DME fault memory is empty.
  • The engine has been re-adapted.
  • The engine runs in stratified charge mode.
  • The learnbits at ../F5/Shift+F6/F2 show correctly completed adaptations.
  • The temperature-dependent bank adaptations at ../F5/Shift+F5/F4 are correct.
  • There is no permanent vibration. Rough running at ../F5/F7 shows correct mechanical efficiency of every cylinder, so the mixture of each cylinder is also correct.
  • Both offset-type and multiplicative-type LTFT are correct.

The adaptations of all connected systems (throttle, tank ventilation valve, EGR) are also correct. There are no mass misfires. The hiccup happens only once, at a certain time after the engine starts.

Conclusion

I have no doubt that this is a software bug, one of many. Unfortunately it cannot be fixed properly, because the latest software releases for the MSD80/81 date from around eight years ago.

When a strong hiccup is justified

Strong hiccups of this kind can have real causes, and the following applies to the N43 as well:

  • Oil pressure problems. If the DME detects that the required oil pressure cannot be maintained for several seconds, it switches to emergency mode. The oil pump then holds maximum oil pressure until the next driving session. A strong hiccup occurs at the moment of switching, and the DME stores a static oil-pressure fault.
  • Fuel pressure problems. If the HPFP cannot maintain the required pressure for a longer time (5+ seconds), it is switched off. The engine falls back to emergency mode at 5 bar, supplied by the LPFP, and the hiccup is felt. The DME stores a static HPFP pressure fault.
  • Battery SOC/SOH data problems. If the battery was not registered correctly after replacement, or not registered at all, the IBS reports a negative SOH and does not work correctly. Regular hiccups can then occur because the alternator management algorithms fail and the vehicle voltage occasionally drops below the permitted limit.
  • Internal DME reset. Several causes can trigger it, for example a complete system crash due to a leaking injector, HPFP overpressure valve problems and other defects. This event is recorded only in the Info list and can be seen only with INPA (..F4/F2/F3). The fuel mixture is completely wrong at the moment of the shudder. Faults are usually stored as well, for example for HPFP pressure drop or plausibility, and these too may be recorded only in the Info list.

BEYOND THE FAULT CODE

A clearer picture.
A better next step.

Get in touch
Enlarged technical image
Open original image