Skip to content
Shop
Explore

INDEPENDENT BMW ENGINE EXPERTISE

Car with known history. Really?

N43 / N53 · NOXEM · DIAGNOSTICS

Select a technical image to view it in detail.

An owner of an N53 came to me again. After the NOx system repair the situation had improved, but the car still switches off stratified charge, and sometimes vibration can be felt.

The owner says the car has a well-documented history. He says he keeps all the paperwork confirming that the dealer replaced all injectors in 2010 and again in 2013. That sounded good, since injectors fitted in 2013 should be the 11th release, the current one at the time. Hoping there would not be many problems, I started checking the diagnostic data.

Diagnostic data

The situation with the injectors is a complete nightmare:

  • Injector No. 2 has electrical problems.
  • Injector No. 2 also leaks catastrophically at idle, and injector No. 4 drips strongly at idle.
  • Injectors No. 2, 3, 4 and 6 have inadequate flow-rate adaptations in stratified charge mode.
  • Injector No. 2 has abnormal flow-rate adaptations in homogeneous mode. The data for the other injectors is questionable and should be re-evaluated after injector No. 2 is replaced.

Finally, here is the fuel mixture data after a warm start. This time I did not even ask for cold-start data.

Lambda by bank was 1.20 and 0.82, and the LTFT offset in bank 1 was 1.50. A complete crash.

What the injectors look like

The car supposedly has new injectors, fitted in 2013. So what could have happened to them? I asked the owner to send me pictures of the injectors.

My conclusions from the pictures:

  • All injectors are genuine BMW parts.
  • Injectors No. 3, 4, 5 and 6 are from one batch.
  • Injectors No. 1 and 2 are from different batches.

Why the replacement story does not hold up

In a typical case, the injectors are exchanged like this:

  • The dealer reports the recall case to BMW AG.
  • BMW AG sends a full set of new injectors.
  • The dealer replaces the injectors and puts the old ones on the shelf until BMW AG decides what to do with them: send them for expert examination, refurbish them or scrap them.

This time the scenario was clearly different. The injectors come from three different batches, and the oldest was already about one and a half years old at the time of replacement. I find it doubly suspicious that exactly four injectors are from the same batch. It is quite possible that a set from an N43 engine was installed in this one, which would mean they were already used when fitted. The injector from cylinder 1, being one and a half years old, was in any case already used.

Either way, the story of the dealer replacing the injectors and everything being perfect until yesterday falls apart. The dealer story itself also fell apart: the replacement turns out not to be confirmed by any documents. The only source is the previous owner of the vehicle.

Why was the original story so convincing? Possibly the current owner wanted to avoid the scenario of replacing all the injectors and then seeing what happens next. Such tricks achieve nothing. I base my decisions on live data, and I do not ask for everything to be replaced indiscriminately. This time the live data says these injectors have been “cleaned” and “tested” with a very dirty cleaning liquid, which is the only way I can explain their completely incorrect performance.

The injector of cylinder 2 has fundamental problems, but the others are also very far from correct operation and will not survive the coming winter.

BEYOND THE FAULT CODE

A clearer picture.
A better next step.

Get in touch
Enlarged technical image
Open original image