Skip to content
Shop
Explore

INDEPENDENT BMW ENGINE EXPERTISE

The battery don’t needs to be registered. Really?

N43 / N53 · NOXEM · DIAGNOSTICS

Select a technical image to view it in detail.

Over several earlier posts (here and here) I described how important it is to register a battery replacement. The registration has to be done correctly, not with tools made by third parties, and the battery has to be replaced on time. Many of you may have concluded that I exaggerate: nothing happened to your car, and a friend who replaced his battery without registering it had no trouble either.

This entry may change your mind.

How little battery a car needs to start

A vehicle in good technical order needs only a small percentage of the battery’s capacity to start in summer. The start current can also be much lower than the figure printed on the battery. In winter the demands grow, but even in very cold weather a small share of a full battery’s capacity is enough if the car starts on the first or second try.

The real test comes in winter, when the car doesn’t start on the third, fourth or fifth try, or when it has been left for a long time without going to sleep. Everything is relative, and I can’t say that, for example, “at -20 °C this battery can start the car 10 times without any sign of weakness”. My point is that we car users don’t actually know the true condition of our battery. We find out about its poor performance only when the car no longer starts. Most BMW owners drive cars whose battery is much weaker than it should be, yet nothing gives a sign of it.

The case: an E90 that shudders after a cold start

Today’s car is a 2009 E90 with an N43 engine. Several months ago its basic problems were solved: the CCV system was put in order and a NOXEM was installed. All parameters looked correct. When colder weather arrived, the owner began to complain that the cold engine shivers strongly right after starting. My first thought was a leaking injector.

I connected INPA with an outside temperature of -3 °C. The car had stood outside for more than 12 hours. Before starting I checked the pressures: both low pressure and rail pressure were around 4000 hPa, so no injector appeared to be leaking in the closed state.

Two entries were stored in the DME error memory:

  • Oil pressure (static). The mechanic plans to investigate this in the near future. It has been recorded about 70 times since the errors were last cleared.
  • An IBS error, status passive, recorded just once about 1000 km earlier.

I ruled out both as possible causes of such strong, repeated shivering.

What happened on the test start

The engine started very evenly. Low pressure was correct and rail pressure was normal, around 150,000 hPa. After a few seconds the DME began warming up the wideband probes, which showed Lambda 1.00 on both banks, and the integrators were correct. Had the defect really disappeared?

Then the engine suddenly shivered strongly. RPM dropped to 300–400, the interior lighting became noticeably dim, and after a second the engine recovered very reluctantly. For the next 10 seconds or so it ran perfectly, then came another one-second “pause”. The engine kept shivering like this roughly every 10 seconds. The EML symbol lit up from time to time, but no error was stored in the DME memory.

At the moment of the shiver I noticed these symptoms:

  • Low pressure and rail pressure disappear. They drop quickly and recover after the event.
  • Lambda on both banks rises right after the shiver to around 1.3–1.5, so the mixture is lean and there is not enough fuel.
  • Onboard voltage drops abruptly. Between the events the alternator holds around 14.4 V, and no generator errors are present.

The direction of the problem came from the Info list: ../F4/F2/F1

Note: INPA is the only diagnostic tool that shows the error messages of the Info list.

Note: the screenshot was taken later, after the problem was eliminated, which is why the status is passive. During the problem session it was active, and the odometer reading confirmed that the entry was recorded at that exact moment.

Hot restart of the DME?

An MSD-series DME can do this. It is rare, and usually much less pronounced: the DME restarts for about half a second and the problem doesn’t repeat for a long time. Over several hundred thousand km, my own car’s DME has restarted like this only a few times.

Here the restarts lasted much longer and the electrical supply almost disappeared. The alternator was evidently disconnected via the BSD. Fuel pressure vanished because the EKP switched off the low-pressure fuel pump. No EKP under-voltage errors were recorded, which makes sense, since the pump was deliberately disconnected for a short moment via the management interface.

This error is registered 16 times. Unfortunately, its attributes don’t say what happened. SPI (Serial Peripheral Interface) is used in the MSD for communication between peripheral units such as memory chips and ADCs. What status 16 means, only the DME developers know.

Was the DME damaged? Were some chips sending faulty data? Was a PCB contact breaking? All of these are possible, but I decided to check the IBS data first. I had reasons to suspect the IBS:

  • The IBS sensor error had been recorded, even if only once.
  • The alternator was disconnected at the moment of the problem.
  • At the start I had a subjective feeling that the battery was not in good condition.

Together these symptoms told me that one of the IBS procedures had been carried out incorrectly.

The IBS data

Here is the data from the IBS system:

Do you see anything suspicious? I have marked the incorrect values:

SOH has reached a negative, impossible value. The energy balance data for the last days is completely illogical and unrealistic. The charge data for the current day is also wrong: the IBS tries to keep SOC in the 60–80% range, and since the car had been standing in the cold, the charge could in no way be 99%.

The data also shows that, despite the car’s age of 10 years, the battery had never been replaced. With a Start-Stop system, such a long service life for the original battery is not realistic.

Note: a negative SOH value can occur when the IBS “thinks” the existing battery has gone far too long without replacement. It thinks so because nobody told it about a replacement. The time (aging) component of the IBS is to blame here, and it is why even a new battery with perfect technical parameters can be treated as hopelessly damaged.

The energy balance data in this menu shows that the counters have overflowed and gone around “a second time”.

Replacing and registering the battery

The owner said the battery had not been replaced in the last few years. The battery had evidently not been charged correctly for a long time, and so had worn much faster than it would have with proper management. I decided to replace it and register the new one correctly.

When the old battery was out, we noted a few interesting points:

  • It is not a cheap aftermarket unit but a BMW OEM battery.
  • It was manufactured in 2013, so it is certainly not the car’s first battery.

The owner clearly did not try to save money. The specialists who replaced the battery, however, evidently knew nothing about the need to register it.

I registered the new battery with ISTA D.

Attention: register the battery only with ISTA D/+/P. Even INPA tends to register it incorrectly, never mind software from other developers.

This is the confirmation of a successful registration.

After registration I checked the IBS parameters with INPA.

INPA also confirms that the battery is registered. More importantly, all the energy management data of the previous battery has been deleted.

The SOH data and the battery test counters have been deleted as well. The IBS management has started a new life.

Cold-start tests the next day, after the battery was replaced and registered, showed that the shivering and the interrupted charging were gone.

A software bug nobody will fix, and no way to diagnose it

This was of course a software bug. Unfortunately nobody will fix it, because this car model is no longer in production.

What troubles me more is something else. BMW has built a truly advanced IBS system, yet ISTA, the tool available in dealer service, gives practically no access to the system’s hidden data, so the problem cannot be diagnosed correctly. Worse, when the battery wears out because the IBS misunderstands its state, no error is logged at all. If there were one, batteries would get registered after replacement and many problems, including ones that seem unconnected to the IBS, would be avoided.

Finally, a dealer would most likely not identify this problem, because INPA is prohibited there. ISTA D shows neither the Info list errors nor the battery’s energy balance and other hidden data. The dealer would most probably order a new DME. The problem would then disappear, because the IBS registers in the new DME would be clean and correct. But it would only disappear for a while, until the IBS noticed that the battery’s SOH was low. EUR 1500 would have been spent unnecessarily, and after some time the battery performance problem would return.

BEYOND THE FAULT CODE

A clearer picture.
A better next step.

Get in touch
Enlarged technical image
Open original image