Skip to content
Shop
Explore

INDEPENDENT BMW ENGINE EXPERTISE

B58. Misfires. Nightmare. Part 2

N43 / N53 · NOXEM · DIAGNOSTICS

Select a technical image to view it in detail.

In the first part of this entry, I described how a B58 behaves when the AC is damaged.

What interested me most was that the engine shook so violently that the DME actually registered some misfires. Here I look at how well it did that job. The source is the same set of screenshots as in the first part: a 2.5-minute recording at idle.

Start of the recording

In the first image, the only misfire shown across the whole screen is in cylinder 5. In fact, there is also a misfire in cylinder 4 at the 6th second, which the DME misses. I examined the image magnified, and no trace of other misfires appears in the background.

At the 22nd second there is a misfire in cylinder 1, and again the DME does not react.

At the 50th second there is another misfire in cylinder 1, and again the DME does not notice it.

Where the DME starts to react

At the 66th second, cylinder 4 comes very close to a full-fledged misfire, and the DME does not notice this event. At the 73rd second, the misfire counter of cylinder 5 is finally cleared. At the 79th second there is a misfire in cylinder 2, and this time the DME is up to the task.

At the 95th second, cylinder 2 misfires again, and the DME notices this one too.

At the 110th second, cylinder 6 comes close to a misfire, but the DME does not notice it. A second later, an identical failure occurs in cylinder 2, and this time the DME notices. At the 20th second, there is a misfire in cylinder 2 that the DME does not notice. At the 122nd second, cylinder 2 fails again, and the DME notices it.

At the 135th second there is a misfire in cylinder 1, and the DME sees nothing suspicious. At the 149th second there are misfires in cylinders 4, 3 and then 2, and the DME notices none of the three.

Observations

The most striking point is that the DME detected misfires only in cylinder 2. Everything else it completely missed.

There is one more nuance. The DME often does not clear its misfire counters for a long time, even tens of seconds, and this includes cylinders that are working correctly. Could this be a hint that the engine is running unstably all the time? If so, it is one more fault.

Conclusions

My conclusion is that a psychic with a crystal ball would do no worse. I have one question: how did misfire detection that performs this badly make it into series production? How can such an algorithm have been offered for 8(!) years already? If the method does not work at idle, it should be switched off in that mode. What is the point of a system that reports so incorrectly? Is it meant to hint that everything should be replaced: all the spark plugs, ignition coils and injectors?

BEYOND THE FAULT CODE

A clearer picture.
A better next step.

Get in touch
Enlarged technical image
Open original image