Skip to content
Shop
Explore

INDEPENDENT BMW ENGINE EXPERTISE

B48. Everything is fine. Is it?

N43 / N53 · NOXEM · DIAGNOSTICS

Select a technical image to view it in detail.

This time it is a G20 330i with the B48 engine, a 2019 model with only 36,000 km on the clock. The spark plugs were replaced 10,000 km ago. About 5,000 km after that, misfires started, and that was another 5,000 km ago. The engine shakes hard at regular intervals, including at idle. Despite these clearly visible and noticeable symptoms, the BMW dealer claims everything is fine: the DME has no stored faults, so there is supposedly no problem.

But what is the reality? Is the customer imagining a problem that does not exist? The owner sent me the data I needed: misfire counters and Rough run data (Expert mode).

Misfire counters at idle

We start with the misfire counters. The engine is warm and idling. Here are some screenshots from the video:

First, a short note on how ISTA reports these counters. The counter of each cylinder is reset after some time. The reset intervals differ from cylinder to cylinder and cannot be predicted. Typically they are between 1 and 10 seconds. This causes several problems:

  • If the misfire happened more than 10 seconds ago, all counters are guaranteed to be 0, so there is no information about which cylinder is at fault.
  • Each cylinder is reset at a different moment, and the intervals vary widely and unpredictably. Even when checking the counters, it is therefore unclear which cylinder is the culprit. The cylinder with the most misfires may have just been reset. Even over a longer observation, a cylinder that misfires the most but is reset more often will show lower counter values.
  • Identifying misfires at idle is a serious challenge for the Bosch DME. I have mentioned the patent war between Siemens and Bosch several times in my blog. This makes identification even more problematic, and the DME identifies the culprit cylinder very poorly.

BMW AG, I have a question for your engineers. Why are the misfire counters for the current session cleared regularly? What is the reason? Please delete those few lines of code (all the code for timing the reset intervals becomes useless as well) and stop clearing these counters. It would make identifying misfires much easier. The functionality you introduced only made the problem harder to find.

What the counters show in this case

The counters show misfires on all (!) cylinders. Cylinders 1 and especially 3 are “healthier”, but they still misfire regularly.

Can we single out particularly defective cylinders? Cylinder 2 most probably has the “poorest health”, but it could also be cylinder 4. What could have happened to all the cylinders, with two of them affected more strongly?

In addition, there are no entries in the DME fault memory, and we can assume that the fuel mixture is more or less correct, at least as far as the DME can tell.

Now to the dealer’s claim that everything is fine. Really? The owner reports a strong shaking of the engine, and the misfire counters confirm it: several tens of misfires on each cylinder in less than one minute. The engine shakes permanently, and there is no doubt about it. How can you tell the customer that everything is OK? Obviously, your “specialists” are not only unfamiliar with the call-up functions and live data, but have also never driven a correctly working BMW. It’s pathetic.

Rough run data in Expert mode

The actual misfires are marked in red. There is no room for interpretation here: it is one cylinder, shown by the green graph, and it is cylinder 2.

It is also evident that the cylinder with the blue graph had increased mechanical energy, especially when cylinder 2 failed most often. This is cylinder 1. Why? The DME sees that the average mechanical energy of cylinder 2 is reduced, because during a misfire its energy is 0. It tries to compensate with the next cylinder in the firing order. The firing order of the B48 is 1/3/4/2, so cylinder 1 follows cylinder 2. The DME increases the amount of fuel injected into cylinder 1 to make up for the “weakness” of the preceding cylinder.

And here is the continuation of this video:

No surprises: cylinder 2 keeps misfiring, and all the other cylinders perform perfectly.

Conclusions

The culprit is cylinder 2, and only cylinder 2. Unsurprisingly, the Bosch DME has serious problems identifying the defective cylinder at idle.

With a probability of 99.9%, the problem lies in the ignition system. Why such a verdict? There are regular, fairly long periods when cylinder 2 performs correctly, for example from the 8th to the 13th second. In those five seconds there are 25 to 30 ignition cycles, which is enough to show that this cylinder can run stably with correct mechanical efficiency. So there is no mechanical defect and, with high probability, no injector problem. In my experience, I have not met injectors on these engines whose spray pattern would be so incorrect, even sporadically, as to cause such problems.

It is sad that, not for the first time, the BMW AG dealer proved completely helpless, and the owner had to drive 5,000 km with a car that shakes. More important, such misfires damage the catalytic converter, an exhaust component that costs several thousand EUR. Will the dealer compensate for catalyst damage if it occurs? I doubt it. Most probably “natural wear” or some other reason will be blamed, and in the end the customer will pay for everything.

BEYOND THE FAULT CODE

A clearer picture.
A better next step.

Get in touch
Enlarged technical image
Open original image