Skip to content
Shop
Explore

INDEPENDENT BMW ENGINE EXPERTISE

B58. Chip tuning. A little about data

N43 / N53 · NOXEM · DIAGNOSTICS

Select a technical image to view it in detail.

A local tuning specialist kindly provided the data for this review: a G31 540i with the B58 engine. The tuner claimed the torque was raised from 450 Nm to 550 Nm, a full 100 Nm. That would be an impressive gain, so is it real?

The chart

The black curve is the tuned result and the red curve is the initial one. I added two green lines, one at the 450 Nm reference and one at the 550 Nm reference.

What the curves show

The initial curve. Either BMW delivers more than the rated figure, or the dyno slightly “decorates” the result.

The tuned curve. It reaches the proud 550 Nm (the automatically generated mark) only around 2100 RPM, in a very narrow spot. Nowhere else does it exceed 540 Nm. Above 4500 RPM the average torque is 530 Nm. That is the range actually used with an automatic gearbox.

The gain between the two curves is also smaller than claimed in most of the range. Around 3000 to 3500 RPM the increase is closer to 50 Nm than 70 Nm, let alone 100 Nm. The claimed 100 Nm difference is possibly reached only between 5400 and 6000 RPM. Of course, 100 Nm sounds far more impressive than, say, 65 Nm.

Automatic or manual

With an automatic gearbox, a torque increase at 5500 to 6000 RPM matters far more than one at 2500 to 3500 RPM, because the gearbox does not use that low range in kickdown. With a manual transmission the situation is the opposite: the lower range is used much more often.

Conclusion

I will not repeat the methodology of the measurements, which you can read in other blog entries. Nor will I go into the simple tricks, such as taking the worst result as the initial one and the best of several attempts as the tuned one. That stays on the tuners’ conscience. Without disputing that the curves show a torque increase, this case is an example of how data can be manipulated almost without lying.

In absolute numbers, the graph shows that this time there are no 550 Nm to be found. The result is closer to 530 Nm. And if the same energy were “squeezed” out of the initial curve as out of the tuned one, my gut feeling says the gain over 500 Nm, which the Performance and Sound kit offers, would not be so impressive.

BEYOND THE FAULT CODE

A clearer picture.
A better next step.

Get in touch
Enlarged technical image
Open original image