Skip to content
Shop
Explore

INDEPENDENT BMW ENGINE EXPERTISE

Engine damage

N43 / N53 · NOXEM · DIAGNOSTICS

Select a technical image to view it in detail.

The topic is clear from the title, so I’ll go straight to the technical information.

This problem is typical of N43 engines. I have identified more than 10 cases, but none so far on N53 engines.

Symptoms

  • Poor idle quality in Homogenous mode: chaotic extra vibration and shivering without misfires. In some cases the vibration is permanent and cannot be fixed. The culprit cylinder with reduced efficiency can be identified, but replacing the injector and re-adapting does not help.
  • Idle in Stratified charge is correct, and the problems disappear as if they had never been there.
  • All live data and adaptation values are correct.
  • Fault 2D06 “Air mass system. Air mass – too high (zu hoch)” is stored.

Here are freeze-frames from two different vehicles/engines:

A short summary of each case:

  • In the first car, cylinder No. 3 had an unsolvable loss of mechanical efficiency in Homogenous mode (../F5/F7). Its cylinder efficiency was around +40 to 60 units, which means the efficiency is lowered by roughly 30–40%.
  • In the second car, all cylinders worked more or less equally at idle (about ±10 to 30 units), but idle quality was poor, and the fault could not be cleared even with a new MAF, new lambda probes and so on.

The freeze-frame suggests that the airflow data are wrong, so the MAF (air mass meter) is the obvious first suspect. Unfortunately, replacing it did not help in any case, whether I fitted a MAF from another working engine or a new OEM sensor. Replacing the MAP sensor and the throttle did not help either. The EGR data were correct.

The most interesting point is that everything disappears in Stratified charge. The symptoms go away, and no faults are stored in the DME fault memory while the car runs in that mode.

Checking the crankcase gas flow

In all cases I observed a significantly increased gas flow in the crankcase. To evaluate it:

Test 1

  • Start the engine and do not touch the accelerator pedal. This guarantees that the engine runs in Homogenous mode.
  • Open the oil filler cap. If you feel a strong, vibrating airflow, the situation is suspicious and you should move on to the next test.

Test 2

  • Block the CCV air duct to the intake manifold at the point marked in the image.
  • Start the engine and open the oil filler cap.
  • You can ask someone to work the accelerator pedal for a short while.

If you feel a significant, pulsating airflow directed outwards, there is a problem. This is an example of significantly increased gas pressure in the crankcase:

What it means

Some combustion gas always reaches the crankcase, and it can only get there by passing between the piston and the cylinder wall. In a healthy engine this flow is held back by the tiny gap between piston and wall and by the compression rings. If a large amount of gas gets past both barriers, the problem is not limited to one component of the piston group.

A note here: it is the N43 engines that have problems with increased crankcase pressure. The situation is much better on the N53. Up to a certain point, this gas pressure does not cause any problems. It is normal, inevitable engine wear.

If you find such a gas problem, unfortunately the engine needs a serious repair. The wear of the block and pistons must be checked, and any part that is over the limit must be replaced. The compression and oil rings have to be replaced as well.

Further observations

In conclusion, here are some observations that may be useful.

On the engine where one cylinder stubbornly stayed “lazy” in Homogenous mode, I ran the cylinder switch-off test (../F9/F2). This test block lets you switch off cylinders one after another. Note that the cylinders are displayed in firing order. When I switched off the lazy cylinder, the amount of gas in the crankcase dropped significantly. That was one more confirmation that this cylinder was the culprit.

In parallel I measured the compression of each cylinder. Interestingly, it was within the allowed limits. It may have been about 0.5 bar lower than the other cylinders, but it was still within limits.

I then ran a cylinder leakage test. Unlike the compression test, whose most sensitive stage is near the very top of the stroke, the leakage test can reveal gas leaks at other piston positions, such as mid-stroke and the lowest position. Unfortunately, the leakage test did not show any large losses either.

I have two explanations for these negative results:

  • During the test the pressure is only around 2 bar, while in a running engine it is several dozen times higher. Higher pressure may deform the rings, even more so if they have been overheated and have become “soft”.
  • The test is done at room temperature, but combustion gases are several thousand °C. If the piston (and/or the block) is badly worn, the hot gases hit the rings in large volume and overheat or deform them.

My recommendation is not to rely on compression and leakage tests. The conditions in which they are performed are very far from the engine’s real operating conditions. Measurements of cylinder mechanical performance (INPA or ISTA readings) and an assessment of the amount of crankcase gas give more reliable results.

By the way, to evaluate crankcase gas pressure, BMW AG suggests a special tool, IMIB, which is actually a regular manometer. Pipe A5E0134072 is attached to it, and the other end is screwed in place of the oil filler cap, which lets you assess the crankcase pressure. This test is not correct without the CCV pipe blocked, but it is still better than nothing.

BEYOND THE FAULT CODE

A clearer picture.
A better next step.

Get in touch
Enlarged technical image
Open original image