Skip to content
Shop
Explore

INDEPENDENT BMW ENGINE EXPERTISE

B58. Idle. Some nuances

N43 / N53 · NOXEM · DIAGNOSTICS

Select a technical image to view it in detail.

This time I’m summarizing some nuances of idle management in the MEVD 17.2.9.

Telling the idle mode apart

It’s a shame that the status bits indicating DME’s performance mode are exposed neither in the call-up functions nor in Expert mode. For example, the fact that the Vector method is being used to stabilize idle can be detected only from the control probe readings.

With the “regular” idle stabilization method, Lambda in the exhaust is close to 1.00. The catalytic converter consumes almost all the oxygen, and the control probe reads around 0.70 V.

With the Vector method, Lambda in the exhaust is close to 1.01, so a small amount of leftover oxygen passes into the exhaust. The target voltage of the control probe is around 0.30 V.

Evening out cylinder performance at idle

The following images show how DME starts to even out the mechanical performance of the cylinders at idle.

At 240 s, I shifted into neutral and continued to reduce speed. Cylinder No. 4 (yellow curve) is a bit “lazy”, but while the car is moving DME does not even try to fix this. At 255 s the speed reaches 0 and the car stops. At that moment DME starts to even out the cylinders.

Over the next 5 to 15 seconds, the mechanical efficiency of all cylinders is evened out.

Still, the smoothness of the engine is not perfect. Why?

At 278 s the misfire counters are cleared (this time in cylinders No. 4 and No. 6). Why did DME detect misfires? As I found out here, DME detects misfires every time I change gears.

Misfire counters and the manual gearbox

My observations show that while the misfire counters are active, and for some 10 to 15 seconds after they are cleared, DME “watches the situation” and does not restore the Vector injector adaptations. Only when it sees that there are no misfires does it start restoring them. As a result, in a car with a manual gearbox, idle will not be as smooth as it could be for the first several tens of seconds (even up to a minute) after stopping.

Unfortunately, this can be fixed only with a software update. The fix would be quite simple: if the clutch is pressed, even briefly, stop detecting misfires. It is only a few lines of code, yet it has not been done in 8 years, since BX8 has been in active service.

A second remark: why does DME not even out cylinder performance while the car is still moving? The reason is simple. A car with an automatic gearbox typically stays in gear. Even in eco mode, when the gearbox disengages, the torque converter keeps working and creates a varying load while the car moves. My car, however, has a manual gearbox, which is mechanically disengaged. If the cylinders were evened out in this state as well, idle would be perfect by the time the car stops. Again, a few lines of code, but nobody cares about such “small things”.

Refueling with the engine running

One more nuance: see what happens if the car is refueled without shutting down the engine.

At 307 s, DME detected refueling. I understand the reasoning: for safety (for example, if low-quality fuel is added), the fuel octane/quality data must be cleared and relearned, and ignition must be retarded for a moment. But maybe this could be done more smoothly? The engine shivers and idle drifts. The efficiency of cylinder No. 2 becomes badly wrong, dropping for a moment by as much as 20 to 30 %. DME then smooths out the cylinders over 5 to 7 seconds.

At 352 s, DME switches on the Vector stabilization method, and you can clearly see the change in idle smoothness. Even the smallest “teeth” disappear. Cylinder No. 2 is now a bit too active, and DME will need another 10 to 15 seconds to correct it. But…

When DME finally manages to smooth out the idle, it detects yet another refueling event! The BMW engineers could have done this better here, for example by adding a timer that waits until refueling is finished. Again, a few lines of code, but… maybe I want too much?

BEYOND THE FAULT CODE

A clearer picture.
A better next step.

Get in touch
Enlarged technical image
Open original image