Select a technical image to view it in detail.
In internet forums, a frequent question is which BMW engine is the cheapest to maintain and run, or at least which engines should be avoided.

If you buy a used car, nobody can tell you how much you will have to invest in the vehicle or its engine, but certain tendencies can be predicted. 8-cylinder and S-series engines clearly won’t be the cheapest, so in this entry I briefly summarize the most popular 4- and 6-cylinder engines of the N series.
4-cylinder engines
N40. A relatively exotic engine, built as the 1.6-liter N40B16 and sold in limited numbers in some countries. It has no Valvetronic, so it is poorly equipped and cheap in every respect. The only problem may be finding used spare parts.
N45. An uncommon low-power engine without Valvetronic. The situation is similar to the N40.
N42, N46. These engines already have Valvetronic. Despite the widespread myths about worn eccentric shafts and other Valvetronic components, I cannot confirm them. In my assessment, the cause of persistent vibration at idle (with reduced mechanical efficiency of cylinder 4, or of cylinders 3 and 4) is trouble with the intake HVA. These problems come from infrequent oil changes.
All the engines above have been the cheapest BMW 4-cylinder engines to own for the last 10+ years.
N43. A direct-injection engine with stratified charge. It is much more expensive when repairs are needed.
- Piezo injectors cost 500+ EUR each and tend to start leaking in cold temperatures.
- The HPFP costs around EUR 350, but defects are fairly rare.
- The NOx system, in its original form, lasts around 100,000 km (catalytic converter) or about 10,000 to 20,000 km (sensor). Repair is expensive, at 5000+ EUR. The catalytic converter costs around EUR 4000 and the sensor around EUR 500.
- The engine requires regular driving at speeds above 110 km/h.
It is very fuel-efficient, powerful, responsive and refined, but repairs are undoubtedly much more expensive than on the engines above. It is also complicated, and only a small number of diagnostic specialists can handle it.
N20, N26. Turbocharged engines. The good news is that they no longer use Piezo injectors. The bad news is that the new, more robust injectors also turned out to be problematic. Follow the factory recalls (injectors, wastegate control, DME and, if I remember correctly, the HPFP was also replaced). Nothing is eternal, but these engines are durable.
B48. The latest BMW engine (along with the 3-cylinder B38). As with the 6-cylinder B58, already known technology has been refined. There is nothing innovative or especially interesting here, but experience so far shows these are long-lasting engines without marked weak spots. Of course, the turbocharger is not eternal, and maintenance is not cheap either: OEM BMW spark plugs cost EUR 25 each.
6-cylinder engines
M54. I included it because it was fitted in the first years of the E60 with MS45 management. A good old workhorse, and the cheapest engine to maintain. It has no Valvetronic, so even clicking hydraulic compensators won’t cause trouble. An unbeatable engine.
N52. It has Valvetronic, but it causes no problems as long as the oil is changed promptly. It is the cheapest option among the late-production 5 Series and other BMW sedans.
N53. A direct-injection engine with stratified charge, and the most expensive 6-cylinder engine to maintain.
- It has Piezo injectors, which tend to leak.
- The HPFP, which can unfortunately fail, costs EUR 700.
- The NOx system (with a catalytic converter costing EUR 6000) has the same lifespan as on the N43 described above.
- The CO catalytic converters are damaged if they are not replaced promptly. The same fate awaits them if the NOx system is left unrepaired for a long time. They cost around EUR 4500, with no alternatives.
- The engine requires regular driving at speeds above 110 km/h.
It is an excellent engine when in good technical order: fuel-efficient, responsive, refined and powerful, with a strong reaction to the accelerator pedal. Unfortunately, it is expensive and complicated, and only a few specialists can repair it correctly.
N54. A modified N53 with turbocharging. It has no stratified charge, so there are no NOx system problems. BMW tried to reduce injector leaking at idle, but the injectors still cause trouble, and they are the same expensive Piezo injectors as on the N53. In addition, the N54 has two turbochargers, which wear out, and no Valvetronic. These engines are powerful but not economical, which is worth remembering if you want to save on fuel. The HPFP is identical to the N53’s; these pumps are expensive and not eternal.
N55. A modernized turbocharged 6-cylinder with a single turbine, cheaper and more robust injectors, and an HPFP similar to the N43’s, with a longer service life. It has Valvetronic, so the remark about oil changes and HVA applies. Otherwise it is a durable, long-lasting engine.
B58. The current engine, replacing the N55. Experience to date shows it is long-lived and has no weak spots. A real workhorse. Some may be surprised that OEM spark plugs cost EUR 25 each, but this is BMW, and BMW is not the cheapest car among its competitors.
A note on the B38/B48/B58 family
I said above that the B38/B48/B58 are nothing innovative, but that is not a bad thing. These engines run at 11:1 compression. Even in stoichiometric mode they use a “layer” (stratified) mixture formation principle: the fuel does not mix evenly with the air as in the “old” engines, but is ignited directly at the moment of injection to avoid detonation.
The practical consequences are these:
- They require high-quality spark plugs, which have to be replaced relatively often.
- The injectors must be in perfect order, and the demands on their performance are much higher than on the “old” N42/N46/N52 engines.
- The oil should be high quality and changed regularly.
- Do not use plain water in the cooling circuit.