Select a technical image to view it in detail.
Several readers have asked me two questions:
- Is it normal for the engine to run a bit unevenly right after starting, with an increased idle speed?
- What are the parameters of this after-start stage, and when is it time to worry?
What the DME does after a start
For the first 60 to 90 seconds after the start, the DME deliberately heats up the CO catalytic converter. It does this in two ways:
- It holds an increased idle speed of around 1000 RPM.
- It turns the exhaust VANOS to a position where the exhaust valves open while combustion is still in progress. The fuel therefore keeps burning in the CO catalytic converter, and its temperature rises quickly.
The purpose of this heating is to reduce harmful emissions.
F-series cars with the B58 engine have no exhaust temperature sensor. The DME simulates the exhaust temperature by calculation. BMW AG’s engineers apparently don’t trust their own simulation, because the DME stubbornly repeats the heating cycle even when a hot engine and exhaust are restarted several times.
Why the engine runs unevenly
During the warm-up cycle the engine does not run in a “normal” mode. The flame spread differs noticeably from cycle to cycle. If the valves on one side of the combustion chamber open in the middle of such an unstable process and let burning fuel escape, we cannot expect perfectly even running.
Even so, the engine feels average to me subjectively. The raised idle speed helps a lot, because the flywheel damps the unevenness, and the higher the RPM, the better it does so. My short answer is that you should start to worry when you feel significant unevenness or shaking of the engine (misfires).
ISTA also warns that engine running is more uneven while the CO catalytic converters are heating up:

Unfortunately, BMW AG publishes no information on the permitted level of unevenness. Zero data, as usual.
Measurements: Rough run menu, Expert mode
Below are two examples from a normally running B58 engine, recorded in the Rough run menu in Expert mode.
Example 1: cold start at +20 °C
This was a cold start on a summer morning. On the X-axis, the timeline begins at the start of the engine.



During the first several tens of seconds, the unevenness reaches around ±15% (sometimes even 20) units.


After around 70 seconds, the heating of the CO catalytic converters stops and the idle speed gradually drops to 650 RPM. The cylinders run more evenly, and the short-term unevenness no longer exceeds 4 to 5 units.
Engine running after 5 minutes at idle:

Engine running after 10 minutes at idle. The coolant temperature has reached 80 °C, and the oil temperature indicator in the KOMBI starts to move:

Example 2: restart of a warm engine
Here the engine was already at operating temperature. On the X-axis, the timeline again begins at the start.



During the first 60 seconds, while the CO catalytic converters are being heated, the short-term unevenness reaches ±10 units. When the heating stops, the running quality improves quickly.


What happens when heating ends
Judging by the character of the unevenness, once the CO catalytic converter heating is finished, and provided the engine has reached operating temperature, the DME switches on the updating of the individual injector adaptations (the prognosis of mechanical efficiency). The quality of the DME’s “guessing” of the ignition corrections for each following cycle clearly improves. The efficiency changes of each cylinder are no longer an up-and-down zigzag line, as they are while the catalytic converters are heating, but a line of very soft changes.