Select a technical image to view it in detail.
In the previous entry (here), I described a case confirming that a defective AC, or another related load such as the cooling fan, alternator or automatic transmission, degrades the engine’s idle quality. I wrote that after the repair all symptoms disappeared, and that even with the AC switched off (via the button on the IHKA panel) everything was ideal.
I was wrong.
A second B58 with a poor idle
Diagnosing another B58 showed me the problem. Its idle quality was poor. There were no full-blown misfires, but short-term unevenness reached +/- 7 .. 10 units. That indicates deep instability: the short-term mechanical efficiency of a cylinder deviated by as much as +/- 10 .. 15 % from the ideal.
The VANOS positions were correct. Valvetronic jittered slightly, but just enough to hold the average idle RPM. So what was wrong? Were the spark plugs worn out?
I happened to notice that the owner never uses the AC. I asked him to turn it on, to rule out any influence from the switched-off AC on the data.
A moment later, while we were stopped at the roadside, both of us noticed that the idle had become much smoother. All the problems had disappeared, and the live data confirmed it: the situation was radically better.
Testing on my own car
After seeing this, I decided to check on my own car whether the idle differs depending on whether the AC is on or off.
Remark: in my blog I have previously described my observation that the MSD80/81 (BMW E-series) stops updating the individual injector adaptations at idle / in stratified charge if the AC is switched off. I have no information about other adaptations being disabled, but it is quite possible that the injector adaptations are not the only ones.
To test whether switching off the AC has a dramatic effect on idle in an F-series B58 car, I left the AC off for a longer time. At first nothing changed. Over the next 3 .. 5 minutes, however, I could feel increased short-term unevenness. It was not a constant vibration but a jerking idle. The RPM and the idle character also changed whenever the load changed, for example when the IHKA fan speed increased.
This is how the idle looks 5 minutes after switching off the AC:


The short-term unevenness is clearly above the norm. There is also increased unevenness over the medium term (one, two or three seconds). Sometimes a cylinder shows incorrect mechanical efficiency for several seconds.
Now the most interesting part:

At the 145th second I switch the AC on. Look at how radically the stability of the idle changes.
Thirty seconds later the idle is perfectly stable. The first two images cannot even be compared with this one.

Here the AC is ON, but the requested cabin temperature is +30 °C. We can assume the AC compressor power is 0, because the requested temperature is high. The idle is perfectly fine.

Here the requested temperature is +19 °C. Again everything is fine and the idle is correct.

And this is how the B58 idle looks after driving for a longer time with the AC switched off:

Where the cause lies
My explanation may not be accurate, because it rests only on my own observations. As usual, the manufacturer provides no data.
When the user switches the AC off with the button on the IHKA panel, the DME has no way to check that the AC compressor is working properly. Consequently it cannot verify that the reported mechanical load corresponds to reality. The situation resembles a damaged AC. This time the consequences are milder, and it appears that only the updating of the individual injector adaptations is switched off.
How the individual injector adaptations work
As I mentioned in the previous entry (here), the DME predicts the engine’s mechanical load and, from that, calculates how much additional fuel to inject to keep the idle perfect. As we might expect, this prediction is not always ideal. One of the reasons is the injectors and the nuances of how they behave in these engines.
In full-function mode (AC on), the DME analyses every cycle of every cylinder and checks how well it predicted that cylinder’s mechanical efficiency. If the prediction was wrong, the adaptation map of the injector concerned is corrected immediately.
For example, the DME determines that the mechanical load will increase by 10 Nm or 20 %. From the energy calculation it concludes that the injected fuel quantity must increase by 1 mg/stk. After the injection, it finds the result was not ideal: the cylinder’s mechanical efficiency rose by 15 % instead of the planned 20 %. Evidently the injector is slightly “lazy”. The DME then modifies the adaptation of that injector so that the efficiency in the next cycle matches the ideal. In the next cycle it again evaluates whether the ideal efficiency was reached and whether the adaptation map needs further correction. This is how the DME tries to achieve a perfect idle prediction.
Why the idle degrades a few minutes after the AC is switched off
If the AC is off, the creation of these adaptations is switched off too. For the first moments everything is fine, but a few minutes are enough for the idle quality to drop. Why?
The B58 works with high rail pressure (100 bar at idle, up to 300 bar when driving), and the injector opening times are very short. At idle the injector spends 30 % to as much as 50 % of the time in the so-called “fly” mode, in an intermediate position between closed and open. This intermediate state is very unstable, and the DME has to correct the voltage and current supplied to the injector regularly, because injector parameters change with temperature, rail pressure and so on. It is precisely because of this long, unstable intermediate state that Bosch had to introduce these additional adaptations.
Remark: some time ago Bosch was forced to admit (the information is in TIS and is mentioned here) that these new-generation injectors have more significant problems than planned. For the N20/26 engines, for example, there was an injector upgrade (from EU5 to EU6, changing the size of the injection beam). An electrical wastegate was introduced as well, but most importantly, a major software upgrade followed. That upgrade is intended to introduce fly-time adaptations for these injectors.
Conclusion
In my opinion this is definitely a flaw. It is not acceptable for the idle quality to degrade just because the user switches off the AC. But I don’t think BMW AG will listen.