Skip to content
Shop
Explore

INDEPENDENT BMW ENGINE EXPERTISE

F10/11. Problem solved?

N43 / N53 · NOXEM · DIAGNOSTICS

The owner of this car lives 2000 km from me, and almost everything I know about the problem came to me by e-mail. My access to information was very limited: I received only what the owner chose to share. How it ended is described below. In my opinion, the case is a useful lesson in how not to repeat this BMW enthusiast’s experience. There won’t be many pictures in this entry.

The case

About a year ago, the owner of a BMW F10 approached me with a typical story. The car had around 190,000 km on the clock, and the DME fault memory contained errors for the NOx sensor. The car had been driven for a long time with a damaged NOx system. The uneven running had been “solved” by replacing every component anyone could think of.

When the ideas for chaotic part replacement ran out (or the owner got tired of wasting money, or ran out of it), he decided to try the NOXEM. The local “specialists” kept claiming that the NOx system affects nothing. After a long exchange and many confirmations that the NOx system is in fact very important, he bought and installed the NOXEM.

The car came to life. Some unevenness remained during cold starts, but the owner did not pursue it. Probably he considered it normal for a cold engine to shiver, and the local “specialists” probably said the same.

A year later he contacted me again. Fault 12C401 had appeared in the fault memory, and resetting the adaptations did not help. I explained why this fault is stored, but he was not interested in such complicated matters. The local “specialists” had told him that since there was a NOx sensor error, the sensor had to be replaced. I asked him to send me DME live data so we could find out why Stratified charge was being prohibited. He sent nothing.

Shortly afterwards he told me he had installed an OEM sensor and that the shivering of the *warm* engine was gone. Problem solved!

Excuse me? Shivering of the warm engine? This was the first I had heard of it. It’s a pity, because had I known, I could have suggested solutions. But it was his choice which problems to tell me about and which to leave out.

In his opinion the problem is solved. In mine, new problems have been created, EUR 500 has been spent for nothing, and the “funniest” part is still to come.

Why I don’t believe the problem is solved

1. The NOXEM signals were consistent for a year. The NOXEM measures most of the parameters (linear Lambda, binary Lambda, temperature) and sends them to the DME in real time. The DME also requires the sensor to follow its commands regularly and immediately. If even one parameter is wrong, the DME immediately stores a series of NOx sensor faults (12C501, 12C502, 12CA01, 12CA02, etc.). The signals the emulator measures are real. The NOx signal, by contrast, is calculated mathematically and cannot “degrade” over time. If the DME was satisfied with these signals for a year and then suddenly something changed, even a layperson can see that the change happened on the car’s side.

2. The NOx catalytic converter is almost certainly dead. In my experience with several thousand of these engines, I have seen only two (!) whose NOx converter was still working after 200,000 km. Both were driven on German highways and kept in perfect technical condition. Statistically, then, the chance that the NOx converter of this car is healthy is about 0.1%. In reality it is zero, because the car ran for a long time with a damaged NOx sensor before the NOXEM was installed. On such a car, once an OEM NOx sensor is fitted, Stratified charge is switched off immediately and never comes back, because the DME now receives the information that the NOx catalytic converter is bad. N53 engines of the F series do not tell the driver about this problem. BMW chose this strategy of hiding problems to reduce the number of complaints.

3. The OEM sensor did not cure the cause. I have no reason to doubt that the shivering disappeared after the OEM sensor was installed, whether that sensor is new, used, working or carrying a hidden typical defect. The owner told me about the warm-engine shivering only after the “repair”. Had he told me before, he would have saved EUR 500. One typical cause of such shivering is misfires. Misfires make the car shiver, and when the DME sees this shivering it prohibits Stratified charge from time to time and stores fault 12C410. The result is a paradox: the sensor reporting an excellent NOx converter “causes” the shivering, while the sensor reporting a damaged converter “solves” it?

The DME defines the injection mode, and with it Lambda, VANOS and the parameters of other components. The NOx sensor only decides whether the DME may allow Stratified charge. Everything else is up to the DME. So the NOx sensor does not cause the shivering. Stratified charge does.

Why a warm engine shivers in Stratified charge

Why does a warm engine shiver in Stratified charge but not in Homogeneous mode?

In fact, the engine also shivers in Homogeneous mode under certain conditions, for example when it is cold or when the requested torque rises sharply (kick-down). In these conditions the fuel is harder to ignite than at low load. According to the owner, this car had certainly been shivering during cold starts for a long time. He may have regarded this behavior as normal, and I have even heard “specialists” at BMW dealerships say that it can happen with these engines. No, it is NOT normal. An N53 engine in good technical condition starts perfectly even at −25 °C, without any vibration or shivering.

Back to Stratified charge. At low load, this mode places higher demands on the ignition system components and on the initial injector parameters than Homogeneous mode does. There are several reasons:

  • Very lean mixture. In Stratified charge the average mixture is very lean (Lambda 2 to 3.5), and such a mixture does not burn on its own. To solve this, the fuel is ignited right next to the spark plug, where the mixture is richer, while the rest of the combustion chamber stays lean. If the injector “makes a mistake” and the mixture near the spark plug is not rich enough, a misfire occurs.
  • Specialized ignition hardware. To guarantee ignition, these BMW engines use special spark plugs with a much wider gap than in “regular” engines. Their ignition coils also deliver much higher voltage and power. This higher output increases the load on these components, raises the demands on them and shortens their lifespan.
  • Wet spark plugs. If the injector places the fuel even slightly too close to the spark plug, the plug gets wet and a misfire occurs. Unlike in Homogeneous mode, the fuel is ignited at the moment of injection. It has no time to mix with air, and the spark plug has no time to dry. The following BMW image shows how close to the spark plug the injector sprays the fuel.

[[KEEP1]](https://bimmerprofs.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/bmw_GDI_spray_pattern.png)

A defect in any of these components (spark plugs, ignition coils, injectors) can cause misfires, and none of them lasts forever. Spark plugs last 20,000 to 30,000 km, and much less if the engine has increased oil consumption or if any injector leaks or misfires. Ignition coils can “quit” after only a few tens of thousands of km. The injectors of the 11th release also have their surprises. A hard particle (debris, or a piece of rust that got into the fuel system) can lodge in the nozzle, and the injector starts to leak soon after replacement.

Consequences for the owner

1. Stratified charge is gone for good. With the OEM sensor, the DME does not allow Stratified charge and will never allow it again. With every drive, the injector adaptation maps drift further from the correct values. No new injector data will be collected and the adaptations will not be updated, because the most important injector measurements (leakage and response time, for example) are made in Stratified charge mode itself. For a while the DME will try to work with the old adaptation maps, but when that fails, engine vibration, uneven running and the load on the CO catalytic converters will increase. Eventually the car will not pass the technical inspection, and later it will not be possible to drive it normally.

2. The smooth running is an illusion. The problems have not disappeared and have not been solved. The car shivers during cold starts, and after a short while it will shiver with a warm engine as well. Even now, the unburned fuel from cold starts is entering the exhaust system and permanently damaging the CO catalytic converters and Lambda probes.

3. Fuel consumption will rise. If the owner drives fast enough for the DME to start a desulfation session, the average fuel consumption and the load on the exhaust system will increase even more, especially on the already damaged CO catalytic converters. A new CO catalytic converter costs around EUR 1500, and cheaper alternatives are unfortunately not available.

Conclusion

In my opinion, the owner spent EUR 500 completely uselessly and has created many problems for the future.

I expect that after some time, when vibrations appear and the misfires get worse, he will start replacing parts all over again, injectors included. The fault memory will then show errors for individual cylinders rather than for the NOx system. Yes, BMW’s habit of hiding problems is wrong, and yes, diagnosing these engines is difficult. But that is exactly why I created this blog: to help you avoid unjustified repair costs. Of course, you have a choice. You can use this information to your advantage, or do exactly the opposite.

BEYOND THE FAULT CODE

A clearer picture.
A better next step.

Get in touch
Enlarged technical image
Open original image