Skip to content
Shop
Explore

INDEPENDENT BMW ENGINE EXPERTISE

B58. Misfires. Experiment. Part 3

N43 / N53 · NOXEM · DIAGNOSTICS

Select a technical image to view it in detail.

I would recommend that every buyer of a B58 receive an unlimited supply of Xanax or a similar sedative.

You may ask why.

The failure after the experiments

When I finished my experiments, I put the “correct” ignition coil back into the cylinder 2 seat. The coil I used for the experiments will not go into daily driving. Everything should have been fine. I started the engine. After a few seconds, several misfires began, and a second later one of the cylinders was already shut off. The car started to vibrate, and the DME began to “dry” the spark plugs, with the familiar howling coming from the engine compartment.

Unfortunately, it only got worse. Clouds of smoke came from the exhaust, with a pungent smell. The car vibrated, the engine shook, and the EML blinked.

I connected ISTA to record as much of this event as possible.

What the recording shows

In the image, we see:

  • The combustion time of all cylinders is correct, so this is not a mistake I made when refitting the ignition coil.
  • An abnormal number of misfires in cylinder 3 (!), followed by cylinder 2.
  • Third place goes to cylinder 4, which also has a large number of misfires.

At the 13th second the misfire counters are cleared and counting starts again. The order, starting with the highest count, is now cylinders 2, 3 and 4, and the remaining cylinders have problems too.

A complete engine crash!

Isn’t that impressive?

The fault memory data

The attributes stored with these many “damaging” error messages are even more impressive:

There is not a word about the fuel mixture. Nothing on LTFT or STFT; the data is zero. Was there not enough space in the list?

Meanwhile, there are three (!) records of the fuel level in the tank. One would be enough: the fuel level on the pump side. There are also four (!) records of coolant/engine temperature.

Against this background, the record of ambient pressure looks funny. Maybe Bosch foresees some global abnormality? Perhaps they have had experience with mass misfires caused by completely wrong fuel pressure? Maybe Bosch is getting ready to run these engines in space?

The cause of the crash

The reason is quite trivial. After the CO catalytic converter warm-up phase, Bosch “does not see” misfires as long as the combustion time stays more or less correct, and all the LTFT values “go crazy”. I wrote more about this problem here.

In my humble opinion, the DME algorithms fail completely in this situation. The DME sees significant abnormalities in the amount of air consumed, in the mechanical efficiency of the engine and in the exhaust gases. What is the point of changing LTFT significantly under these conditions? Such desperate “adapting” leads to one result: a harsh drop in engine performance after the engine is restarted, if the cause was misfires on some cylinder and the problem disappears after the restart.

Misfires are the most common problem in petrol engines. Yet a few seconds of misfires brought the engine to the point where the vehicle would have to be taken to a workshop on a tow truck. Very impressive, Bosch!

The solution

The fix is to readapt the engine. Of course, the cause of the misfires must also be corrected; I think there is no dispute about that.

BEYOND THE FAULT CODE

A clearer picture.
A better next step.

Get in touch
Enlarged technical image
Open original image