Skip to content
Shop
Explore

INDEPENDENT BMW ENGINE EXPERTISE

B58. Ignition. Total failure

N43 / N53 · NOXEM · DIAGNOSTICS

Select a technical image to view it in detail.

Decades have passed since Siemens and Bosch developed the DME for petrol engines, so the basics should be in order by now. Would that be logical? Yes. Let’s see how Bosch is doing with the latest MEVD 17.2.9 management on the B58 engine, starting with the basics of the ignition.

Multi-ignition: documentation versus reality

TIS says multi-ignition is used.

ISTA is more specific: multi-ignition is used in all engine performance modes up to 2000 RPM.

Here is the actual ignition oscillogram:

The events occur every 180 ms (5.5 times per second), so there is one per combustion cycle. Zooming in:

And at the moment of discharge:

I saw the same picture on a cold engine, a partially warmed one and a fully warm one, both at idle and at raised RPM.

So where is the multi-ignition? That is a question for Bosch, because there is none. The DMEs of the previous generation did have it, but those were Siemens DMEs.

The DME stores no error messages, and there is no obvious reason for it to switch the feature off. Why would it?

Why it is switched off: overvoltage in the primary circuit

I have an answer, and it comes from what goes wrong during each discharge. Look at the marked area:

This is the moment when the DME’s ignition switch has just closed and the voltage in the circuit rises rapidly. At the marked point the voltage reaches around 420 V and then suddenly collapses.

A short digression: which ignition switches does the MEVD 17 DME use? EcoSpark® 2 (2nd generation) switches, for example the FGD3040 or NDG8201. Here is their datasheet:

The maximum allowed voltage is 400 V. Above that, the built-in overvoltage protection acts. When it does, the transistor is opened repeatedly. The energy stored in the coil is dissipated in the transistor at the moment of switching and released as heat.

Why does the voltage overshoot? There are several reasons:

  • The voltage in the primary circuit of the ignition coil rises at around 150 V/µs, so the critical limit (400 V) is reached after about 3 µs. Creating an arc at the spark plug takes longer (at least 5 to 10 µs). During those first microseconds the voltage rises uncontrolled.
  • Besides the “perfect” ignition coil, there is so-called stray inductance, which would produce a voltage surge even if the spark ignited immediately, because a huge amount of energy is released very rapidly.
  • The wires from the DME to the ignition coils add another voltage spike. Each wire is an inductance, although a small one, and this should not be forgotten.

There is one more interesting nuance in the datasheet, marked here:

The shutdown (current fall) time of these switches can differ by as much as 7 times. Depending on the batch or individual part (not to mention temperature), the switch can shut down whenever it likes. In one case the problem described here will be larger, in another smaller.

I already noticed this problem on the MSD80-generation DME, described here.

What the repeated emergency opening does

  • It reduces the useful energy, because part of it is lost.
  • It heats the switches significantly, because the lost energy is released in them.
  • It can make spark creation unstable. The voltage in the circuit drops, and the arc is disrupted at that moment.

On top of this, the uncontrolled, increased voltage damages the ignition coils prematurely.

On my MSD80 I solved all of these problems by installing snubbers, as shown in the link above. Afterwards:

  • The heating of the ignition switches dropped significantly. I evaluated this with a thermal camera, not “by senses”.
  • The lifespan of the ignition coils increased significantly. Before the snubbers I replaced coils “in a circle”; afterwards it became so rare that I forget where and when I bought any of them.

All the symptoms point to the following:

  • Bosch has drawn no conclusions, and the overvoltage problems are in full swing.
  • The ignition switches run too hot because of the repeated opening, so multi-ignition is not an option.
  • Unstable idle and misfires at idle are, without any illusions, consequences of the same problem.

Test with a snubber

For the test I built a snubber from 0.1 µF and 33 Ω. After connecting it:

The maximum voltage dropped from 420 V to 260 V, and no voltage “shivering” was observed.

In this oscillogram you can see how stable and even the arc is, just like in a school textbook:

For comparison, here is how the spark is created without the snubber:

This is a complete nightmare. The transistor appears to open repeatedly, even several times. The voltage shivers, so the arc is certainly not stable.

Current, inductance and connector load

Here is one more graph (right side of the image):

It shows that at high temperatures these switches start to have trouble at a current of just 15 A (the inductance of the B58 ignition coil is 1.0 to 1.5 mH). Together with the heating problem, this looks like one more reason to switch off multi-ignition.

Compared with the previous generation of coils, the primary winding inductance has fallen from 2.5 to 3.0 mH to 1.0 to 1.5 mH. At the same time the charge time has increased (from 2.2 ms to 2.5 ms). This means the current through the switches, wires and connections has risen significantly, to 15 to 18 A.

There may be yet another reason to disable multi-ignition: the connection of this generation of ignition coils may not be able to withstand such a load. The connector contacts are so tiny that common sense says regular 15 to 18 A current pulses through them are a severe overload.

Given these ignition problems, it is no surprise that some owners of these engines report smoother idle after reducing the spark plug gap from the default 0.75 mm to 0.50 mm. A smaller gap reduces the overvoltage problem and requires less energy to maintain the arc. Of course, this fights the consequences, not the cause.

Coil limits and BMW’s documentation

Here are the technical parameters of the ignition coil:

Let’s calculate the maximum primary voltage: 29000 / 80 = 363 V. So the maximum allowed voltage in the primary circuit is 363 V. With the actual primary voltage of 420 V, the secondary circuit reaches 33,600 V, which is 16% (4600 V) above the maximum allowed.

The datasheet states exactly 29000 V, which makes clear that even a 30000 V limit is not acceptable. Yet the limit defined by the manufacturer itself is exceeded serially and constantly, in every cycle, not occasionally or in emergencies. I think every technically minded person will doubt the longevity of ignition coils working under such conditions.

The cherry on the cake is the manufacturer’s own description of the ignition system. Two paragraphs of text “about nothing” can be forgiven, but the graphic is a masterpiece:

The I curve may still be approximately true, but the U curve (green) is complete nonsense. Even assuming the authors forgot to mention the use of a 1:10 probe, the situation does not get better. BMW, what is this? Who drew it, who approved it, and who has not fixed it for years? I wonder how many ignition systems have been “fixed” thanks to this masterpiece.

If BMW AG cannot find the correct picture (and cannot make any measurements itself), I offer this image found on the Internet. It is not perfect, but at least it is correct.

Cylinder 6

On my own car I observed increased unevenness of cylinders 2 and 6 at idle. Given the firing order (1/5/3/6/2/4), it is clear that the search should start with cylinder 6.

Why could cylinder 6 be the most problematic on these engines?

The marked area shows additional sound insulation above the HPFP. The pump does run very loudly, and the insulation is there for a reason. But it completely paralyzes the air exchange around the ignition coil of cylinder 6, so that coil works in an abnormal temperature regime. Its connection wires had turned petrified. You can read more about overheating here.

Conclusion

There are at least four reasons why multi-ignition is switched off, and why these engines have and will have problems with the ignition.

BEYOND THE FAULT CODE

A clearer picture.
A better next step.

Get in touch
Enlarged technical image
Open original image