Skip to content
Shop
Explore

INDEPENDENT BMW ENGINE EXPERTISE

12C401. Plausibility: signal activity too low

N43 / N53 · NOXEM · DIAGNOSTICS

Nuances to take into account when installing a NOXEM 402. If your car has an OEM NOx sensor, fault 12C401 typically means the sensor cell is damaged (clogged).

12C401 right after installing the NOXEM

If 12C401 is recorded directly after installing the NOXEM (during the engine’s re-adaptation, the first few hundred km), the DME has noticed an unexpectedly good NOx catalytic converter performance. “To be safe”, it has flagged the sensor data as suspicious.

Unlike the first-generation N53 engines, the second generation (installed in the F10/F11) has no way to register a NOx catalytic converter replacement. There is therefore no way to tell the DME that the NOx system has been repaired. In this situation:

  • Delete the fault codes.
  • Delete the NOx sensor adaptations, as described here.
  • Re-flash the DME software using ISTA P/+. On some ZB releases, the NOx converter status is confirmed not to be renewed or cleared after the adaptations are deleted. In that case, re-flashing the DME software is the only solution.
  • If the fault returns, the engine may have become “stuck” in Homogeneous mode for some reason. A more exact description follows below.

12C401 appearing later

If 12C401 is recorded later (after several hundred, thousand or tens of thousands of km), the typical cause is that the engine has switched off Stratified charge mode and has been running in Homogeneous mode for longer than it should.

Note: in this case 12C401 is not critical and does not cause a malfunction (Stratified charge). If the engine can still use Stratified charge, the data sent by the NOXEM match what the DME “expects” from an exhaust system in perfect technical order.

Why 12C401 is recorded

The NOXEM tells the DME that the exhaust is performing perfectly. The DME accepts this until it has evidence that the exhaust is actually performing poorly, or should be. For example, the DME may calculate that the NOx catalytic converter is contaminated with sulfur (no desulfation session has been performed for a long time). It may also detect uneven cylinder operation, insufficient CO catalytic converter performance, or other problems (more detail below). All of this contradicts the ideal readings from the NOXEM, and the DME concludes that something is obviously trying to fool it, or that the sensor is damaged.

The fault does not prevent the engine from running in Stratified charge mode, and you can even use it to your advantage. Owners of F-series cars have very limited access to the operating conditions and “health” of the N53 engine, far more limited than on E-series cars with N43/N53 engines (details here). ISTA gives no information on the engine operating mode, the NOx catalytic converter contamination or the NOx sensor status, let alone learnbits, misfire counters or other more specific data. Owners therefore cannot know whether, or how often, the engine uses the fuel-saving Stratified charge mode. In this case, 12C401 is a good indicator that you should look into the engine’s well-being.

Typical reasons the N53 gets stuck in Homogeneous mode

1. Contamination of the NOx catalytic converter

This is the most typical reason the MSD87 stops using Stratified charge. ISTA does not delete the converter contamination data when it deletes the engine adaptations. So if you re-adapt the engine with ISTA, you must clean the NOx catalytic converter by performing a desulfation session. This also applies when a NOXEM is installed. It is needed less often than with an OEM NOx sensor, but it still has to be done.

Alternatively, use INPA to delete the adaptations and the NOx catalytic converter contamination (instructions here), and make sure the contamination level reads 0 mg afterwards. If you do not regularly drive at 110–120 km/h or more, check the NOx catalytic converter contamination with INPA, or find a way to make faster drives.

Unlike the MSD80 (E-series N53), the MSD87 does not record a fault for NOx catalytic converter contamination. Such a fault sometimes appears only in the Info list, which is NOT available via ISTA or third-party software. There is also no service procedure to trigger a forced desulfation session. When contamination reaches a critical level, the DME switches off Stratified charge without any notice to the driver.

2. Insufficient CO catalytic converter performance

If the DME detects insufficient CO catalytic converter performance in Stratified charge mode, it turns this mode off for some time. After a while it restores Stratified charge and measures the CO catalytic converter performance again. A fault for reduced CO catalytic converter efficiency is recorded only after quite a long time, or not at all if performance is only slightly below the norm. The engine can therefore rarely use Stratified charge while the DME records no fault.

There is one more nuance. If faults of this type (including current ones) are deleted, they are recorded again only after several hundred km at the earliest, or even thousands. There is no reason for optimism if such faults seem to “disappear” right after deletion.

If you suspect CO catalytic converter problems, first fix any injector problems and excessive oil consumption. Then drive for a long time (at least 1–2 hours) with increased engine load, either at 130–140 km/h or more, or at a lower speed but aggressively. The higher load (temperature) can improve CO catalytic converter performance and at the same time clean sulfur from the NOx catalytic converter. How to check the condition of the CO converters is described here.

Warning: do not use fuel additives intended to “clean” catalytic converters. They can damage the injectors, fuel pumps, lambda probes and the NOx sensor.

Also evaluate the pass/fail counters of the CO catalytic converters (details here). If the current values (over several hundred km) are lower than the average registered earlier, CO catalytic converter performance has clearly dropped significantly.

3. Fuel mixture problems

These are the most unpleasant defects, because they do not immediately produce fault codes in the DME fault memory:

  • Intake manifold air-tightness problems. The most typical culprits are the CCV membrane or the manifold pipe connections. The DME will repeatedly rewrite the offset-type LTFT, re-adapt the fuel mixture of the banks and re-measure the injectors. If the defect is not bad enough to ruin the mixture completely, no faults are stored, but the engine will run in Homogeneous mode for a long time. Details here.
  • Injector problems. If an injector sometimes leaks heavily when closed, injects the wrong amount of fuel or atomizes unstably, the DME switches to Homogeneous mode and tries for a long time to resolve the problem by re-measuring the injectors. If it fails, the re-adaptation process restarts again and again. Sporadic injector problems can disrupt normal engine operation for a long time. Unfortunately, only a small part of the injector corrections is available in INPA, and ISTA shows nothing.
  • Fuel pressure problems and instability. These engines have two fuel pumps connected in series. Unstable fuel pressure is unfortunately not rare. The cause can be the electromechanical low-pressure pump or a stuck HPFP control valve.

4. Uneven engine operation

Stratified charge can also be switched off because of uneven running. The most typical reasons are:

  • Misfires on one cylinder, caused by ignition problems or an incorrect injector spray pattern (more here). Misfires on all or several cylinders can come from poor-quality fuel or incorrect spark plugs (more here). How to check the misfire counters is described here.
  • A false alarm in the DME caused by a rough road. Users of the previous engine generation know fault 3104, which was recorded even when driving on pavement. The F-series DME records the uneven-running fault much more reluctantly, but that does not stop it from switching off Stratified charge at the first “suspicion”.

If you drive on a rough road, or you have felt uneven running (for example from poor-quality fuel), do not be surprised that the engine has switched off Stratified charge. If you feel uneven running quite regularly, check the misfire counters with an ELM327 adapter. Users of INPA and ISTA unfortunately have no access to this misfire data.

5. Any other engine system problem

Even seemingly unrelated faults, such as oil pressure, thermostat function, cooling shutters, fuel pumps or lambda probes, will immediately put the engine into emergency mode. Remember that there are no insignificant systems for this DME, and any fault can have unexpected consequences. If you see any fault in the fault memory, fix its cause.

Conclusion

If 12C401 was recorded once or a few times long ago and the engine has no other faults, there is no reason to worry. If the DME records this fault regularly and recently, find out why it is switching off Stratified charge mode.

BEYOND THE FAULT CODE

A clearer picture.
A better next step.

Get in touch
Enlarged technical image
Open original image